← All problems

Polterovich’s 2002 question on Hofer-metric rigidity

Let (M,ω)(M,\omega) be a closed symplectic manifold, let Ham⁡(M,ω)\operatorname{Ham}(M,\omega) be its group of Hamiltonian diffeomorphisms, and let Ham⁡Aut(M,ω)\operatorname{Ham}_{\mathrm{Aut}}(M,\omega) be the set of time-one maps of autonomous Hamiltonian flows. Is

sup⁡ϕ∈Ham⁡(M,ω)dH(ϕ,Ham⁡Aut(M,ω))=+∞?\sup_{\phi\in\operatorname{Ham}(M,\omega)} d_H\bigl(\phi,\operatorname{Ham}_{\mathrm{Aut}}(M,\omega)\bigr)=+\infty?

Equivalently, does every R>0R>0 admit a Hamiltonian diffeomorphism ϕR\phi_R such that dH(ϕR,Ham⁡Aut(M,ω))>Rd_H(\phi_R,\operatorname{Ham}_{\mathrm{Aut}}(M,\omega))>R?

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new preprint settles the two-dimensional version, but the broader question in higher dimensions remains open and the claim has not been independently checked.

Polterovich’s 2002 question asks whether arbitrarily large Hofer balls can avoid autonomous Hamiltonian diffeomorphisms. Its higher-dimensional form asks for this phenomenon beyond surfaces.

Known results

  • For compact symplectic surfaces of genus g≥1g\ge 1 and every R>0R>0, there exists gR∈Ham⁡(Σ)g_R\in\operatorname{Ham}(\Sigma) with dist⁡H(gR,Ham⁡Aut⁡(Σ))>R\operatorname{dist}_H(g_R,\operatorname{Ham}_{\operatorname{Aut}}(\Sigma))>R.
  • For suitable products Σ×M\Sigma\times M, earlier work established aut⁡(Σ×M)=+∞\operatorname{aut}(\Sigma\times M)=+\infty and powers⁡k(Σ×M)=+∞\operatorname{powers}_k(\Sigma\times M)=+\infty for k≥2k\ge 2, but not the general higher-dimensional conjecture.

October 8, 2026 surface-case preprint

Habib Alizadeh and Egor Shelukhin report that their paper settles the surface case and obtains further results for autonomous flows in selected higher-dimensional settings. The preprint does not resolve the general higher-dimensional question, and its claims remain unverified.

Current status (as of October 2026): The surface case is claimed settled, while the general higher-dimensional question remains open and the new claims have not been independently verified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.