← All problems

Galt–Tyutyanov conjecture on hereditarily G-permutable subgroups

For every nontrivial finite group GG, GG is simple if and only if it has no proper nontrivial subgroup AA that is hereditarily GG-permutable, where AA is hereditarily GG-permutable if, for every subgroup EE with A≤E≤GA\leq E\leq G and every subgroup B≤EB\leq E, there exists a GG-conjugate BgB^g of BB that permutes with AA in EE, equivalently ABg=BgAAB^g=B^gA in EE.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A new unrefereed paper claims to prove the conjecture for all finite groups, but the claim has not been independently checked.

The Galt–Tyutyanov conjecture says that a finite group is simple exactly when it has no proper hereditarily GG-permutable subgroups. It is recorded as Kourovka Notebook Problem 17.11217.112 and is associated with Alexey A. Galt and Valentin N. Tyutyanov.

Known results

  • PSU⁡3(q)\operatorname{PSU}_3(q), q=pf>3q=p^f>3: no proper hereditarily GG-permutable subgroups (Galt–Tyutyanov, 2025).
  • For G≅PSL⁡2(q)G\cong\operatorname{PSL}_2(q), q=pf>4q=p^f>4, proper GG-permutable subgroups are characterized; when pp and (q−1)/2(q-1)/2 are odd, none exist (Galt–Tyutyanov, 2025).
  • Earlier negative results covered alternating, sporadic, and exceptional groups of Lie type.

October 2026 claimed proof

On October 8, 2026, Shengmin Zhang's arXiv preprint claimed a proof for all finite groups, extending the known cases to classical groups via parabolic descent and finite-simple-group factorization. The claim is unrefereed and has no independent mathematical assessment in the retrieved sources.

Current status (as of October 2026): Shengmin Zhang claims the conjecture is proved for all finite groups, but that claim is unverified; the previously established cases remain the only independently documented progress.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.