← All problems

Pełczyński’s problem concerning the uniqueness of symmetric structure

Let EE and FF be separable symmetric Banach sequence spaces, and let CEC_E and CFC_F denote the corresponding ideals of compact operators on a separable Hilbert space. Does CE≅CFC_E\cong C_F as Banach spaces imply that E=FE=F with equivalent norms? Equivalently, must an isomorphism between the compact-operator ideals associated with EE and FF force the underlying symmetric sequence spaces to coincide up to equivalent norms?

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open

The original classification question remains open; related results concern only narrower isometric or embedding versions.

Pełczyński posed the problem at a Banach-space conference in August 1979: whether an isomorphism between compact-operator ideals associated with symmetric sequence spaces forces the underlying spaces to have equivalent norms. The available evidence records no independently assessed solution.

Known results

  • A 2021 preprint proves uniqueness for the narrower isometric analogue of symmetric operator spaces, including the L2L_2 case after a separate argument.
  • A 2020 preprint gives non-embedding criteria for symmetric function spaces into compact-operator ideals, extending results of Arazy and Lindenstrauss; it does not claim to solve the uniqueness problem.

Current status (as of October 2026): Pełczyński’s original isomorphic uniqueness problem remains open in the evidence reviewed; related isometric and embedding results are known, but no independently assessed solution is recorded.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.