Ionization conjecture

Let a molecular system have nuclei with charges Z1,…,ZK>0Z_1,\dots,Z_K>0 and total nuclear charge Z=∑i=1KZiZ=\sum_{i=1}^K Z_i. If NcN_c denotes the maximal number of electrons that the system can bind, then there exists a universal constant CC such that Nc≤Z+CN_c\le Z+C, uniformly in the number of nuclei, their charges, and their positions.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Claimed progress

A new paper claims a sublinear improvement for a simplified two-nucleus model, but the conjectured constant-size excess for the full quantum problem remains open.

The ionization conjecture asks whether the maximum bound-electron number is at most nuclear charge plus a constant, including for molecules. The full many-body molecular statement remains open.

Known results

  • Ruskai and Sigal (1982) proved finiteness of Nc(Z)N_c(Z).
  • Lieb (1984) proved the general bound Nc(Z)<2Z+1N_c(Z)<2Z+1 for atoms, and Nmax⁡<2Z+MN_{\max}<2Z+M for molecules.
  • Solovej (2003) proved the analogous Z+O(1)Z+O(1) result in Hartree–Fock theory.
  • Müller theory also has a Z+CZ+C bound, but this is a reduced theory.

October 2026 two-center estimate

Lu Chen and Yong Wu report, for the two-center Thomas–Fermi–Dirac–von Weizsäcker theory, the bound N≤Z+CZ153/154(1+log⁡Z)3/8N\leq Z+C Z^{153/154}(1+\log Z)^{3/8}. This is a claimed advance toward neutrality, but it does not establish the conjectured Z+O(1)Z+O(1) bound for the full many-body problem.

Current status (as of October 2026): The full many-body ionization conjecture remains open; a two-center bound in a reduced theory is claimed but unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.