Borg’s conjecture on intersecting integer partitions

Let P(n,k)\mathcal{P}(n,k) be the set of integer partitions of nn into exactly kk positive parts. For 1≤t<k1\le t<k, call a family A⊆P(n,k)\mathcal{A}\subseteq\mathcal{P}(n,k) tt-intersecting if every λ,μ∈A\lambda,\mu\in\mathcal{A} have at least tt common parts, counted with multiplicity. Let St={λ∈P(n,k):λ contains at least t parts equal to 1}\mathcal{S}_t=\{\lambda\in\mathcal{P}(n,k):\lambda\text{ contains at least }t\text{ parts equal to }1\} be the canonical tt-star. Borg's conjecture asserts that every tt-intersecting family satisfies ∣A∣≤∣St∣|\mathcal{A}|\le |\mathcal{S}_t|, equivalently that the canonical tt-star is extremal.

References

Primary source

arXiv

Additional references

Progress summary

Refreshed
Claimed progress

A new paper proves the conjecture in a broad large-size range and gives counterexamples elsewhere, so the full question remains open.

Borg (2013) conjectured that the family of partitions containing a prescribed number of common parts is extremal among intersecting partitions. The general extremal problem has both positive results and counterexamples, with intermediate cases unresolved.

Known results

  • For tt-intersection, the star is extremal when n≤2k−t+1n \le 2k-t+1 or n≥3tk5n \ge 3tk^5 (Borg, 2013).
  • In the large-nn range, the star is unique when k≥t+3k \ge t+3 (Borg, 2013).
  • Counterexamples to a universal fixed-length assertion include (n,k)=(8,3)(n,k)=(8,3) for t=1t=1, and more generally (n,k)=(t+7,t+2)(n,k)=(t+7,t+2) (Borg, 2013).

October 2026 star bounds and counterexamples

Yury Person and Thomas Schweser report a large-nn regime in which the star is extremal, together with counterexamples for every sufficiently large kk and each scale parameter dd. This narrows the unresolved region but does not settle the full conjecture; the paper’s claims are not independently verified in the retrieved material.

Current status (as of October 2026): Borg’s conjecture is proved in substantial parameter ranges and disproved as a universal threshold statement, while the remaining intermediate extremal cases are open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.