Toms–Winter: Strict Comparison Implies Z-Stability
For every separable, simple, nuclear, non-elementary C*-algebra A, unital or nonunital, assert that strict comparison of positive elements implies A is isomorphic to A tensor_min Z, where Z is the Jiang–Su algebra. Non-elementary excludes algebras of compact operators. In the Cuntz semigroup Cu(A) of positive elements of A tensor K modulo Cuntz equivalence, strict comparison means: x≤y whenever phi(x)≤phi(y) for every ordered-semigroup functional phi:Cu(A)→[0,infinity] preserving zero and increasing sequential suprema, with strict inequality for every such phi for which 0<phi(y)<infinity. This is the convention following Conjecture 5.1 of Castillejos–Evington–Tikuisis–White. No UCT, unitality, finite trace-boundary, uniform Gamma or finite nuclear dimension hypothesis is added.
Status Open · subcases solved Status review date not recorded in this edition
Listed by ProofAtlas. Status qualification is attributed to ProofAtlas; no full resolution is certified here.
Progress summary
Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.
Solutions 1
Claimed by OpenAI. Claims Jiang–Su absorption from strict comparison in the extended-functional sense for separable simple nuclear non-elementary C*-algebras, including nonunital algebras and unbounded traces, and a more general Cuntz-semigroup criterion.See full solution
Scope relative to this problem: The source strict-comparison hypothesis uses extended ordered-semigroup functionals on the Cuntz semigroup, including unbounded traces and nonunital algebras. This is the source comparison-to-Jiang–Su-absorption direction, not an added assumption of UCT, finite trace-boundary, uniform Gamma or finite nuclear dimension.
GitHub repository: https://github.com/openai/math
- OpenAI-291-02-Cuntz-comparison-and-Jiang-Su-absorption.pdfOpen