← All problems

Birkhoff Conjecture (Near-Boundary Continuous Invariant Foliation)

For every bounded planar billiard domain Omega whose boundary is a C-infinity simple closed curve with everywhere positive curvature, let T be its usual specular-reflection billiard map on the open phase cylinder M=(R/LZ) x (0,pi), where s is boundary arclength and delta is the incoming angle with the tangent. Suppose an open annular neighborhood U of the grazing end delta=0 is foliated by continuous simple closed T-invariant curves, each essential in M and winding once around the cylinder; U and its foliation are invariant under T. Here neighborhood of that end means U contains (R/LZ) x (0,eta) for some eta>0, with no fixed lower bound on eta or on the rotation numbers reached by the foliation. Assert that the boundary of Omega is an ellipse, with circles included. No central symmetry, closeness to an ellipse, period-four caustic or extension of the foliation to the whole phase cylinder is assumed. The invariant-curve formulation is selected directly; an unproved equivalence to a caustic, rational, measurable or polynomial-integral formulation is not part of the target.

Source: Bialy and Mironov, The Birkhoff–Poritsky conjecture for centrally-symmetric billiard tables, introduction and Section 2; continuous invariant-curve near-boundary generalization..

Status Open · subcases solved Status review date not recorded in this edition

Listed by ProofAtlas. Status qualification is attributed to ProofAtlas; no full resolution is certified here.

References

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 2

Claimed by OpenAI. Claims that a bounded strictly convex planar billiard with C-infinity boundary of positive curvature is an ellipse if its phase annulus has a continuous foliation by individually invariant essential simple closed curves filling a full grazing annulus. The foliation may be arbitrarily narrow; a Cantor family with gaps does not meet the hypothesis. Analytic regularity and a physical caustic collar are obtained using companion estimates.See full solutionHide full solution
Claimed by OpenAI. For a smooth strictly convex planar billiard with positive curvature and a full continuous physical collar of smooth closed strictly convex caustics, the manuscript claims that the table is an ellipse, including circles. Every intermediate leaf is required. This is a related rigidity companion with a physical-caustic hypothesis; it does not by itself establish the page’s continuous phase-foliation formulation or their equivalence.See full solutionHide full solution