Jackson–Ren–Zhao semiring-variety interval problem

Let S7S_{7} be the 33-element additively idempotent semiring, and let S70S_{7}^{0} be obtained from S7S_{7} by adjoining a new zero element. Determine the cardinality of the interval [V(S7),V(S70)][\mathsf{V}(S_{7}),\mathsf{V}(S_{7}^{0})] in the lattice of additively idempotent semiring varieties; in particular, determine whether ∣[V(S7),V(S70)]∣=2ℵ0\lvert[\mathsf{V}(S_{7}),\mathsf{V}(S_{7}^{0})]\rvert=2^{\aleph_{0}}.

References

Primary source

arXiv

Additional references

Progress summary

Refreshed
Claimed solved

Two 2026 preprints claim that the unresolved interval has continuum many members and derive a related nonfinite-basis result, but the claims have not been independently verified.

The Jackson–Ren–Zhao problem asks for the cardinality of specific intervals in the lattice of semiring varieties. The cited preprints claim maximal size, namely 2ℵ02^{\aleph_{0}}, for the principal intervals under discussion and attribute the original question to Jackson, Ren, and Zhao.

Known results

  • A January 2025 paper reports that V(S7)\mathsf{V}(S_{7}) has a continuum of subvarieties, with exactly six finitely based ones identified at the lattice base; it leaves broader finite-basis questions open.

January and September 2026 claimed resolution

  • In January 2026, a preprint claimed that [V(S7),V(B21)][\mathsf{V}(S_{7}),\mathsf{V}(B_{2}^{1})] and the corresponding semigroup-variety interval have cardinality 2ℵ02^{\aleph_{0}}. In September 2026, Gao, Ren, and Zhao developed a general sufficient criterion, applied it to S7S_{7} and B21B_{2}^{1}, claimed 2ℵ02^{\aleph_{0}} intervals including [V(S7),V(S70)][\mathsf{V}(S_{7}),\mathsf{V}(S_{7}^{0})], and claimed that every variety in [V(S7),V((B21)0)][\mathsf{V}(S_{7}),\mathsf{V}((B_{2}^{1})^{0})] is nonfinitely based.

Current status (as of September 2026): The cited preprints claim the interval-cardinality question is solved and give related nonfinite-basis results, but these claims remain unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.