Erdős–Sós for digraphs

For every integer t≥1t\ge 1, every oriented tree TT with tt edges, and every loopless digraph DD on nn vertices with no repeated arcs, if opposite arcs are permitted, DD is Eulerian—that is, deg⁡D+(v)=deg⁡D−(v)\deg_D^+(v)=\deg_D^-(v) for every vertex vv—and ∣A(D)∣>(t−1)n|A(D)|>(t-1)n, then DD contains an oriented copy of TT. The bound (t−1)n(t-1)n is sharp.

References

Primary source

arXiv

Additional references

Progress summary

Refreshed
Claimed solved

A preprint claims a complete solution of the directed conjecture, with independent verification still absent.

The problem asks for a sharp threshold guaranteeing every oriented tree in an Eulerian digraph. The September 2026 preprint by Dhruv Mubayi and Jacques Verstraete claims the full directed analogue, including the directed-path case.

Known results

  • Addario-Berry, Havet, Linhares Sales, Reed, and Thomassé conjectured the threshold (k−1)n(k-1)n for embedding every antidirected tree with kk arcs.
  • Graham, 1970, proved a linear bound for the antidirected-tree problem.
  • Burr, 1982, obtained the bound 4kn4kn.
  • Recent work proves dense, approximate, minimum-semidegree, and girth-restricted variants, not the stated Eulerian theorem.

September 2026 claimed solution

Mubayi and Verstraete's unrefereed preprint states a sharp theorem for oriented trees in Eulerian digraphs and explicitly credits GPT-6 Astra. No retrieved source supplies independent verification, a referee report, or confirmation that the result matches the exact problem.

Current status (as of September 2026): A complete solution is claimed in an unrefereed preprint, but the theorem and its AI attribution remain unverified.

  • GPT-6 AstraOpenAIsolved2026-09-10evidence

    Directed Erdős–Sós theorem claimed for Eulerian digraphs

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.