← All problems

Existence of a second symmetric power for the Vámos matroid

Does there exist a matroid NN that is a second symmetric power of the Vámos matroid V8?V_8? Equivalently, does V8V_8 have a second symmetric power?

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An unrefereed 2026 preprint claims to prove that the Vámos matroid has no second symmetric power, settling the question negatively.

The question asks whether the Vámos matroid has a second symmetric power. Earlier literature treated the answer as unknown and conjectured that it does not.

Known results

  • March 2019: a tropical-ideal obstruction for U2,3⊕V8U_{2,3}\oplus V_8 used nonexistence of a suitable quasi-product, but explicitly did not settle V8V_8 itself.
  • January 2024: Matroid Products in Tropical Geometry still posed the existence of a second symmetric power for V8V_8 as open, while conjecturing nonexistence.

September 2026 claimed resolution

A preprint listed on September 8, 2026, titled The Vámos Matroid Has No Second Symmetric Power, claims to prove nonexistence and thereby rules out the corresponding tropical-ideal realization. The claim is unrefereed and has not been independently verified in the retrieved material.

Current status (as of September 2026): The question was open through January 2024, while a September 2026 unrefereed preprint now claims a negative answer; verification remains outstanding.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.