Open arc-decomposition problems of Bang-Jensen, Bessy, Gonçalves, and Picasarri-Arrieta

Given a digraph D=(V,A)D=(V,A), determine whether there is a partition A=A1∪˙A2A=A_1\mathbin{\dot\cup}A_2 such that one of the following holds: (i) D[A1]D[A_1] is a perfect matching and D[A2]D[A_2] has no odd directed cycle; (ii) D[A1]D[A_1] is a perfect matching and D[A2]D[A_2] is strongly connected; (iii) D[A1]D[A_1] is a perfect matching and D[A2]D[A_2] has an out-branching; or (iv) D[A1]D[A_1] is a cycle factor and D[A2]D[A_2] has no odd directed cycle.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Claimed solved

A new paper claims to settle four previously open directed-graph splitting questions by determining their exact computational difficulty, but the claim has not been independently checked.

The entry concerns four specific arc-decomposition decision problems posed in earlier work by Bang-Jensen, Bessy, Gonçalves, and Picasarri-Arrieta. It does not claim to resolve every open question about decomposing directed graphs.

Known results

  • Bang-Jensen, Bessy, Gonçalves, and Picasarri-Arrieta (2022) reported a complete polynomial-time versus NP-complete classification of 120120 arc-partitioning problems for digraphs.
  • Their results include polynomial-time cases such as (connected,connected)(\text{connected},\text{connected}) and ((out-branching,,out-branching)).
  • They reported NP-completeness for ((out-branching,,in-branching)), ((strongly connected,,strongly connected)), and related pairs.
  • A 2021 survey of the area listed broader existence conjectures involving kk-arc-strong digraphs, some of which remain distinct from the four problems here.

August 2026 claimed classification

A newly reported paper claims exact complexity classifications for the four specified open combinations, thereby settling them conditionally where NP-completeness is proved: the corresponding positive decomposition questions have negative answers unless P=NPP=NP. A related arXiv paper explicitly claims NP-completeness for two antistrong decomposition problems, with strong degree and connectivity restrictions.

Current status (as of August 2026): Four specified problems are claimed settled by complexity classifications, but the claim is unverified; broader arc-decomposition questions remain open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.