Elsholtz–Rackham conjecture on sum-free subsets of lattice cubes

For every fixed integer d≥1d\geq 1, let [n]d={1,…,n}d[n]^d=\{1,\ldots,n\}^d, let M([n]d)M([n]^d) denote the maximum cardinality of a sum-free subset of [n]d[n]^d, and let Nd(n)N_d(n) be the number of subsets S⊆[n]dS\subseteq [n]^d such that there are no x,y,z∈Sx,y,z\in S with x+y=zx+y=z. Then, as n→∞n\to\infty, Nd(n)=2M([n]d)+o(nd)N_d(n)=2^{M([n]^d)+o(n^d)}. Equivalently, the number of sum-free subsets of [n]d[n]^d is asymptotically governed, on the exponential scale, by the maximum size of a sum-free subset.

References

Primary source

arXiv

Additional references

Progress summary

Refreshed
Claimed progress

A new unrefereed preprint claims an all-dimensional extremal result, but it does not prove the requested counting statement, so the higher-dimensional conjecture remains open.

The conjecture concerns the asymptotic number of sum-free subsets of lattice cubes. Elsholtz and Rackham resolved the two-dimensional case; the all-dimensional counting claim remains unsettled.

Known results

  • Dimension 22: density 3/53/5 and the corresponding enumeration, Elsholtz–Rackham, 2017.
  • Dimensions 33 and 44: extremal-size conjecture, Lepsveridze–Sun; the cited source gives no publication date.
  • Dimension 22: stability near the extremal stripe, supporting enumeration but not extending it to higher dimensions.

Version-2 all-dimensional extremal claim (date not stated)

A preprint claims that every dimension satisfies the conjectured maximum-size bound ∣S∣≤cd∗nd+O(nd−1)|S|\leq c_d^*n^d+O(n^{d-1}), with extremizers given by hyperplane slices. This is a substantial claimed advance, but it addresses extremal cardinality rather than the number of sum-free subsets, and is neither refereed nor independently verified.

Current status (as of August 2026): The two-dimensional counting case is settled, while the counting conjecture in higher dimensions remains open; an unverified preprint claims only the related all-dimensional extremal-size result.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.