← All problems

Erdős Problem #988 — Spherical-cap discrepancy must grow

62 years old · traced to

Let S2={x∈R3:∣x∣=1}\mathbb S^2=\{x\in\mathbb R^3:|x|=1\} be the unit sphere. For a finite set P⊆S2P\subseteq\mathbb S^2 and a spherical cap C⊆S2C\subseteq\mathbb S^2, let αC\alpha_C denote the surface area of CC divided by the surface area of S2\mathbb S^2. Define the unnormalized spherical-cap discrepancy by

D(P)=sup⁡C∣ ∣P∩C∣−αC∣P∣ ∣.D(P)=\sup_C\left|\,|P\cap C|-\alpha_C|P|\,\right|.

For each positive integer nn, is it true that

min⁡P⊆S2, ∣P∣=nD(P)⟶+∞(n⟶∞)?\min_{P\subseteq\mathbb S^2,\ |P|=n}D(P)\longrightarrow+\infty\qquad(n\longrightarrow\infty)?

Erdős, Problems and results on diophantine approximations (1964) Erdős Problem #988

Background

Erdős posed this question in 1964 as a problem about how uniformly finitely many points can cover the sphere: he expected the minimum discrepancy to be unbounded, noted that the circle behaves differently, and suggested that Roth’s method for the analogous square problem might be useful. The square analogue was proved by Roth; the problem record also notes Schmidt’s extension of that result to higher dimensions. These analogies motivate the spherical question but do not by themselves settle it, since the tested sets here are spherical caps. Erdős, Problems and results on diophantine approximations (1964) Erdős Problem #988

References

P. Erdős, Problems and results on diophantine approximations, Compositio Mathematica 16 (1964), 52–65.

Source: P. Erdős, Problems and results on diophantine approximations, Compositio Mathematica 16 (1964), 52–65.

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.