← All problems

Erdős Problem #906 — Cofinite zeros of high derivatives

70 years old · traced to

For an entire function ff, write Z(g)={z∈C:g(z)=0}Z(g)=\{z\in\mathbb C:g(z)=0\} and, for each nonempty open set U⊆CU\subseteq\mathbb C, set

AU(f)={n∈N:f(n) has a zero in U},N={0,1,2,…}.A_U(f)=\{n\in\mathbb N:f^{(n)}\text{ has a zero in }U\},\qquad \mathbb N=\{0,1,2,\ldots\}.

The question is whether there exists a transcendental entire function ff such that, for every strictly increasing sequence n1<n2<⋯n_1<n_2<\cdots in N\mathbb N,

⋃k≥1Z(f(nk))\bigcup_{k\geq 1} Z\bigl(f^{(n_k)}\bigr)

is dense in C\mathbb C. Equivalently, for every nonempty open U⊆CU\subseteq\mathbb C, the set AU(f)A_U(f) must be cofinite in N\mathbb N. The original wording only requires ff to be nonzero; read literally, it has a trivial polynomial example, since derivatives above the degree vanish identically. The intended nontrivial question is therefore the transcendental case. Erdős Problem #906 Cofinite Zeros of High Derivatives

Background

Erdős recorded the problem in [Er56d] and again in [Er82e, p. 72], where he wrote that it had been solved affirmatively more than ten years earlier but supplied no reference or solver. The surrounding discussion seems to point toward work of Barth and Schneider, but the cited paper does not give the asserted solution. The distinction between density for one chosen sequence of derivative orders and the required condition for every sequence is important: the latter forces every open set to contain zeros of all but finitely many derivatives. Erdős Problem #906 Cofinite Zeros of High Derivatives

MacLane constructed an entire function whose successive derivatives are dense in the space of entire functions. Barth and Schneider treated prescribed discrete zero sets along one constructed sequence of derivative orders. These results concern related behavior of derivative sequences, but do not by themselves give the cofinite condition above. Boas and Reddy also stated a positive theorem about zero-free disks for infinitely many derivatives; a later erratum withdrew the construction supporting a separate theorem in their expanded article. Cofinite Zeros of High Derivatives

References

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.