← All problems

Mazur's finite-components conjecture for rational points

34 years old · traced to

Let XX be a quasi-projective, irreducible variety over Q\mathbb{Q}. Write X(Q)X(\mathbb{Q}) and X(R)X(\mathbb{R}) for its rational and real points, and give X(R)X(\mathbb{R}) the topology induced by the real topology. Mazur’s finite-components conjecture asks whether, for every such XX,

#π0 ⁣(X(Q)‾ X(R))<∞,\#\pi_0\!\left(\overline{X(\mathbb{Q})}^{\,X(\mathbb{R})}\right)<\infty,

where the bar denotes topological closure in X(R)X(\mathbb{R}) and π0\pi_0 denotes the set of connected components. This is the standard variety formulation; the corresponding assertion for algebraic sets is also discussed in the literature. Poonen (2003) Cornelissen and Zahidi (2000)

Background

Barry Mazur proposed this topological conjecture among a group of questions about closures of rational points. His 1995 update traces the motivation in part to work on Hilbert’s tenth problem and Diophantine definability. The finite-components assertion is weaker than another proposed statement: for a smooth variety with Zariski-dense rational points, the closure should be a union of connected components of the real locus. The stronger statement was later shown to be false, so it should not be conflated with the finite-components question. Mazur (1995) Poonen (2003)

The connection with Diophantine definability is structural: a Diophantine subset of rational points can be realized as the image of rational points under a morphism, and such maps are continuous on real points. Poonen records that the conjecture for varieties would imply the finite-components assertion for Diophantine subsets of algebraic sets. Cornelissen and Zahidi also show that the conjecture would rule out a Diophantine model of integer arithmetic in the rationals. These are consequences of the conjecture, not proofs of it. Poonen (2003) Cornelissen and Zahidi (2000)

References

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.