If the class of atomic models of a complete first order theory is categorical in the , is it categorical in every cardinal
Let be a complete first-order theory, and call a model atomic if every finite tuple from realizes a principal complete type over the empty set. Write for the class of such models. For a cardinal , this class is categorical in if it has exactly one isomorphism type of model of cardinality . The question, for each finite , is whether for every complete the implication
holds. The implication is false, even for theories in a countable vocabulary. Baldwin, Definition 18.1 Baldwin, Theorem 26.1
Background
For a complete theory in a countable vocabulary, atomic models are studied as a class with elementary submodels as its embeddings. When this class is nonempty, it has a countable atomic model, and its countable atomic models are isomorphic. The nonemptiness qualification matters: a complete theory need not have any atomic models. In the question, categoricity at the specified cardinal itself guarantees that the class is nonempty. Baldwin, Definition 18.1 and Assumption 18.3
The finite-threshold examples come from the Hart–Shelah constructions of sentences in , with a later simplification by Kolesnikov. Their analysis uses solutions and the possibility of amalgamating them: although the examples have disjoint amalgamation, the behavior of solutions depends on cardinality. This distinction permits categoricity through a finite range without categoricity above it. Complete sentences in a countable vocabulary can also be represented, without changing their model spectrum, by atomic models of a complete first-order theory in an expanded countable vocabulary. Baldwin, Chapter 26 Baldwin, Theorem 6.1.12
References
Status
- Refuted: John T. Baldwin. Categoricity (University Lecture Series 50, American Mathematical Society, 2009) http://homepages.math.uic.edu/~jbaldwin/pub/AEClec.pdf
Progress summary
Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.