Wikipedia geometry item 71: The Kelvin problem on minimum-surface-area partitions of space into equal-volume cells, and the…
The Kelvin problem on minimum-surface-area partitions of space into equal-volume cells, and the optimality of the Weaire–Phelan structure as a solution to the Kelvin problem
References
Primary source
Progress summary
The leading candidate is still unproved, although a recent claimed theorem settles a much narrower tiling problem.
Kelvin posed the problem in 1887: divide three-dimensional space into equal-volume cells with the least total boundary area. Weaire and Phelan found a better arrangement in 1993, but its global optimality remains unknown.
Known results
- Kelvin, 1887: proposed a slightly curved truncated-octahedral foam.
- Weaire and Phelan, 1993: found a structure with about less area than Kelvin’s, disproving Kelvin’s conjecture.
- Kusner and Sullivan: showed that the polyhedral Weaire–Phelan foam beats every foam with Kelvin’s topology.
- Cesaroni and Novaga: established results for restricted periodic or lattice classes, not the unrestricted problem.
Claimed constrained theorem
A recent arXiv paper claims that the Archimedean truncated octahedron uniquely minimizes area among fixed-volume three-dimensional parallelohedra. This is a narrower class than all partitions and does not prove Weaire–Phelan optimality; the claim is unverified here.
Current status (as of September 2026): The unrestricted minimum and global optimality of the Weaire–Phelan structure remain open; a claimed result for parallelohedra does not settle them.
Sources
- zapatopi.net
- arxiv.org
- kenbrakke.com
- plus.maths.org
- arxiv.org
- mathworld.wolfram.com
- en.wikipedia.org
- scientificamerican.com
- en.wikipedia.org
- quantamagazine.org
- ar5iv.labs.arxiv.org
- mathstodon.xyz
- quantamagazine.org
- mathstodon.xyz
- mathstodon.xyz
- scientificamerican.com
- quantamagazine.org
- books.google.com
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.