Banach's simple Lebesgue spectrum problem
Does there exist an ergodic measure-preserving transformation whose Koopman operator has simple Lebesgue spectrum? In the probability-space formulation, take an invertible measure-preserving transformation of a standard nonatomic probability space . Its Koopman operator is . Since constants are fixed, the spectral question is posed on the invariant subspace . The question is whether some such ergodic has a vector whose iterates span that entire subspace and whose spectral measure is equivalent to normalized Lebesgue (Haar) measure on the unit circle. In formulas,
Here is characterized by ; cyclicity gives multiplicity one, while specifies Lebesgue spectral type. Lemańczyk, On Some Spectral Problems in Ergodic Theory A survey on spectral multiplicities of ergodic actions
The wording also covers a distinct infinite-measure version: the historical Ulam formulation concerns an automorphism of an infinite-measure space, described as the real line with Lebesgue measure. In that setting the operator acts on the full space, rather than on the probability-space mean-zero subspace. These formulations should not be conflated; the question’s wording does not specify which is intended. Lemańczyk, On Some Spectral Problems in Ergodic Theory
Background
The problem is named for Banach, and its infinite-measure formulation is associated with Ulam. Its probability version is naturally expressed through the spectral theorem for unitary operators: a simple-spectrum operator is represented as multiplication by on for a spectral measure . For an ergodic probability transformation, removing constants is essential: the constants form a fixed one-dimensional subspace and therefore cannot have Lebesgue spectral type. The challenge is not realizing simple Lebesgue spectrum for an abstract unitary operator, but realizing it as the Koopman operator of a transformation, which imposes additional dynamical constraints. Multiplicities of tensor spectra of automorphisms Lemańczyk, On Some Spectral Problems in Ergodic Theory
A 2008 account of work on Banach’s problem, recalled in a later survey, described constructions realizing all possible even multiplicities of a Lebesgue component. A related analytic connection comes from generalized Morse systems: they have simple spectrum, and the cited survey gives a criterion under which suitable ultraflat trigonometric polynomials with coefficients would yield a Lebesgue component of multiplicity one. This is a conditional route, not an unconditional construction of the desired transformation. Lemańczyk, On Some Spectral Problems in Ergodic Theory A survey on spectral multiplicities of ergodic actions
Progress summary
Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.
Solutions 1
Claimed by OpenAI. The manuscript claims a smooth volume-preserving diffeomorphism of the three-torus whose Koopman operator on the entire mean-zero L2 space has simple Lebesgue spectrum, generated by one bilateral orthonormal orbit. This addresses Banach’s problem in the usual reduced-spectrum convention. The constant functions retain their invariant eigenvalue and are excluded from this Lebesgue-spectrum claim.See full solution
GitHub repository: https://github.com/openai/math
- OpenAI-144-01-A-smooth-three-torus-diffeomorphism-with-simple-Lebesgue-spectrum.pdfOpen