Aaronson–Ambainis conjecture

For every TT-query quantum algorithm AA, there is a polynomial pp such that, for every ϵ,δ>0\epsilon,\delta>0, there exists a classical randomized query algorithm CC making at most p(T,1/ϵ,1/δ)p(T,1/\epsilon,1/\delta) queries whose acceptance probability satisfies Pr[Ax accepts]Pr[Cx accepts]ϵ\left|\Pr[A^x\text{ accepts}]-\Pr[C^x\text{ accepts}]\right|\leq\epsilon for at least a (1δ)(1-\delta) fraction of inputs xx.

Progress summary

Partially solved

The conjecture remains open, but recent results show that broad classes of quantum algorithms cannot achieve exponential speedups on most inputs.

The Aaronson–Ambainis conjecture predicts that every low-degree polynomial with non-negligible variance has a variable of appreciable influence. If true, it would imply classical simulation of quantum query algorithms on almost all inputs using only polynomially more queries.

Known results

  • Dinur, Friedgut et al. (2006): proved a weaker bound with exponential rather than polynomial dependence on the degree.
  • Montanaro (2012): proved the conjecture for equal-magnitude block-multilinear forms.
  • O’Donnell and Zhao (2016): reduced the problem to one-block decoupled polynomials.
  • Bansal, Sinha, and de Wolf (2022): proved it for completely bounded block-multilinear forms, covering a special class of quantum algorithms.

2020 and August 2026 developments

Keller and Klein’s claimed proof was retracted after Ivanishvili identified a fatal flaw in Lemma 5.35.3. In August 20262026, bounded-round and parallel-query coupling theorems established polynomial-type classical simulations in those regimes, showing that exponential separations require substantial adaptivity; neither result proves the full conjecture.

Current status (as of August 2026): Partial simulation theorems are known for important restricted regimes, while the full Aaronson–Ambainis conjecture remains open.

Sources
Sources & referencesView supporting material

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.