← All problems

q=-1 relations between Kasteleyn cokernels and Smith forms

25 years old · traced to

Let GG and G′G' be the symmetry groups specified in the claim, and write MG(a,b,c)−1M_G(a,b,c)_{-1} and AG(a,b,c)−1A_G(a,b,c)_{-1} for the corresponding matrices specialized at q=−1q=-1. Let Sm⁡(N)\operatorname{Sm}(N) denote the Smith normal form of NN. q=−1q=-1 cokernel conjecture. The following relations should hold:

Sm⁡(AG′(a,b,c))=Sm⁡(MG(a,b,c)−1)2\operatorname{Sm}(A_{G'}(a,b,c))=\operatorname{Sm}(M_G(a,b,c)_{-1})^2

when G=⟨1⟩G=\langle1\rangle or ⟨ρ⟩\langle\rho\rangle and G′=⟨G,κ⟩G'=\langle G,\kappa\rangle;

coker⁡AG(a,b,c)−1≅coker⁡MG′(a,b,c)⊕2\operatorname{coker} A_G(a,b,c)_{-1}\cong\operatorname{coker} M_{G'}(a,b,c)^{\oplus2}

when G=⟨τ⟩G=\langle\tau\rangle or ⟨ρ,τ⟩\langle\rho,\tau\rangle and G′=⟨κτ⟩G'=\langle\kappa\tau\rangle or ⟨ρ,κτ⟩\langle\rho,\kappa\tau\rangle, respectively; and

coker⁡AG′(a,b,c)≅coker⁡AG′(a,b,c)−1\operatorname{coker} A_{G'}(a,b,c)\cong\operatorname{coker} A'_G(a,b,c)_{-1}

when G=⟨τ⟩G=\langle\tau\rangle or ⟨ρ,τ⟩\langle\rho,\tau\rangle and G′=⟨G,κ⟩G'=\langle G,\kappa\rangle. This conjecture proposes a cokernel and Smith-form extension of Stembridge's q=−1q=-1 phenomenon for symmetry classes of plane partitions. The source presents it as conjectural and gives no proof or resolution, so it remains open.

References
  1. Greg Kuperberg, “Kasteleyn cokernels”, arXiv:math/0108150 (2002).

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.