← All problems

Beckmann's conjecture on simple atomic objects

Less than 1 year old · traced to

Let XX be the hyper-Kähler variety under consideration, and let E∈Db(X)E\in \mathrm{D^b}(X) be a simple atomic object. An object is 11-obstructed when its obstruction map has rank 11.

Beckmann's conjecture. The object EE is 11-obstructed.

Atomicity is characterized by the cohomological obstruction map having rank 11, while the source notes that the forward implication to cohomological 11-obstructedness is known. Beckmann conjectures the converse for simple atomic objects; the source gives no resolution evidence.

References
  1. Alessio Bottini, Emanuele Macrì and Paolo Stellari, “Hyper-Kähler varieties: Lagrangian fibrations, atomic sheaves, and categories”, arXiv:2603.23033 (2026).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An October 2026 preprint claims to disprove the conjecture with a counterexample, but the claim has not been independently checked.

Beckmann’s conjecture says that every simple atomic object E∈Db(X)E\in\mathrm{D^b}(X) is 11-obstructed. The unresolved issue is whether atomicity forces the obstruction map to have rank 11 for simple objects.

Known results

  • Every 11-obstructed object is atomic, giving one direction of the conjectured equivalence.
  • Assuming Conjecture A, atomicity and 11-obstructedness are equivalent for simple objects (Theorem 1.4).

October 2026 proposed counterexample

On October 14, 2026, Hanfei Guo’s unrefereed preprint claimed that stable atomic vector bundles are 11-obstructed but constructed a simple atomic object outside that subclass which is not 11-obstructed. If valid, this refutes Beckmann’s conjecture; the claim is unverified.

Current status (as of October 2026): The conjecture has a claimed but unverified counterexample, so its general validity remains unsettled.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.