Periodicity conjecture for the twigs of frame groups

Let p≥5p\geq 5 be prime. For a group GG in the frame Fi\mathcal F_i, let R(G)\mathcal R(G) denote the twig: the subtree of Bi\mathcal B_i consisting of the descendants of GG that are not in the frame. For each ii and γ∈H^i\gamma\in\hat{H}_i, the groups Si,m(γ)S_{i,m}(\gamma) are the groups used in the frame construction.

Twig periodicity conjecture. There exist integers e=e(p)e=e(p) and f=f(p)f=f(p) with (p−1)∣f(p-1)\mid f such that, for every i≥ei\geq e and every γ∈H^i\gamma\in\hat{H}_i,

R(Si+f,m(γ))≅R(Si,m(γ)).\mathcal R\bigl(S_{i+f,m}(\gamma)\bigr)\cong\mathcal R\bigl(S_{i,m}(\gamma)\bigr).

This is presented as a variation of Conjecture W of Eick, Leedham-Green, Newman, and O'Brien. The paper gives no resolution, so the asserted eventual periodicity remains open.

References

Primary source

Bettina Eick, Patali Komma and Subhrajyoti Saha, “The frame of the graph associated with the p-groups of maximal class”, arXiv:2512.11379 (2025).

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.