The majorization characterization conjecture for ordinal spaces embeddable in the line
Let be an ordinal space with , and let be an enumeration of its points satisfying the majorization property. Write for embeddability of in the real line. Majorization characterization conjecture. If such an enumeration exists, then
The paper proves that line embeddability implies the existence of an enumeration with the majorization property and states sufficiency for , while explicitly saying that it cannot determine whether sufficiency holds for ; the general assertion is therefore open.
References
- Karsten Keller and Evgeniy Petrov, “Ordinal spaces”, arXiv:2412.17391 (2024).
Progress summary
The conjecture remains open in the published source, while an unverified submission claims a six-point counterexample.
The conjecture asks whether the majorization property for an enumeration of a finite ordinal space forces embeddability in the real line. The paper Ordinal spaces proves the converse implication and formulates this as Conjecture 7.4.
Known results
- Line embeddability implies the existence of a majorizing enumeration (Proposition 7.3).
- Sufficiency is proved for ; for , Theorem 7.5 gives equivalent characterizations.
- For , embeddability is equivalent to having a unique diametrical pair.
- The authors state that they cannot determine sufficiency for .
Community submission (unverified), November 7, 2026
A submitted argument claims a six-point, tie-free ordinal space whose identity enumeration has the majorization property but which does not embed in the real line, thereby refuting Conjecture 7.4. It describes the result as an AI-assisted preprint and expressly notes that it lacks external peer review; the claim is not independently corroborated here.
Current status (as of November 2026): The implication from embeddability to the majorization property and sufficiency for are settled; the general conjecture remains open, with an unverified six-point counterexample claim.
Sources
Solutions 1
A six-point ordinal space with the majorization property that does not embed in the real lineSee full solution
Result and scope. Six-point tie-free ordinal space whose identity enumeration has the Definition 7.1 majorization property for every chain length (repeats, permutations) but which admits no embedding in R; refutes Keller-Petrov Conjecture 7.4 in the range n>5 left open by the source (sufficiency proved only for n<=4).
Complete proof: A six-point ordinal space with the majorization property that does not embed in the real line · PDF.
The paper page contains the supplementary proof-source JSON and extract_sources.py. The linked paper supplies the complete argument and states the precise scope of the Lean certificate, ordinary proofs, supporting computations, and source interpretation. Those qualifications are retained here; a supporting computation is not a proof of a broader statement.
This is an AI-assisted research preprint. Internal review is not external journal peer review. Bounded prior-art searches do not establish worldwide priority. See the paper for formalization and trust limits.