McNamara–van Willigenburg's factorization conjecture for equivalent skew diagrams

From papers

Let D\mathcal{D} and E\mathcal{E} be skew diagrams, and let D\mathcal{D}^* denote the diagram obtained from D\mathcal{D} by rotation through 180 degrees. Write Ei=WiOiWi\mathcal{E}_i=W_iO_iW_i when this decomposition is applicable, and let Wi\circ_{W_i} denote the operation used to combine skew diagrams along WiW_i. Two skew diagrams are equivalent when DE\mathcal{D}\sim\mathcal{E}, meaning that their skew Schur functions satisfy sD=sEs_{\mathcal{D}}=s_{\mathcal{E}}. For some rr, suppose

D=(((E1W2E2)W3E3))WrEr\mathcal{D}=(\cdots((\mathcal{E}_1\circ_{W_2}\mathcal{E}_2)\circ_{W_3}\mathcal{E}_3)\cdots)\circ_{W_r}\mathcal{E}_r

and

E=(((E1W2E2)W3E3))WrEr.\mathcal{E}=(\cdots((\mathcal{E}'_1\circ_{W'_2}\mathcal{E}'_2)\circ_{W'_3}\mathcal{E}'_3)\cdots)\circ_{W'_r}\mathcal{E}'_r.

McNamara–van Willigenburg's conjecture. The diagrams D\mathcal{D} and E\mathcal{E} satisfy DE\mathcal{D}\sim\mathcal{E} if and only if the factors satisfy: E1,,Er\mathcal{E}_1,\ldots,\mathcal{E}_r are skew diagrams; for 2ir2\leq i\leq r, Ei=WiOiWi\mathcal{E}_i=W_iO_iW_i satisfies Hypotheses I--IV; E1=E1\mathcal{E}'_1=\mathcal{E}_1 or E1=E1\mathcal{E}'_1=\mathcal{E}_1^*; and for 2ir2\leq i\leq r, (Ei,Wi)=(Ei,Wi)(\mathcal{E}'_i,W'_i)=(\mathcal{E}_i,W_i) or (Ei,Wi)=(Ei,Wi)(\mathcal{E}'_i,W'_i)=(\mathcal{E}_i^*,W_i^*). Moreover, the equivalence class of D\mathcal{D} contains 2κ2^\kappa elements, where κ\kappa counts factors Ei\mathcal{E}_i in any irreducible factorization of D\mathcal{D} for which EiEi\mathcal{E}_i\neq\mathcal{E}_i^*. This conjecture would characterize equivalence classes of skew diagrams using the sufficient conditions previously established by McNamara and van Willigenburg; the source gives no evidence of resolution, so its status remains open.

Progress summary

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Sources & referencesView supporting material

Primary source

Emma Yu Jin and Shu Xiao Li, “Towards equivalent thickened ribbon Schur functions”, arXiv:2403.01843 (2026).

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.