← All problems

The non-noetherianity conjecture for infinite-dimensional subalgebras of the Witt algebra

5 years old · traced to

Let W≥−1W_{\geq -1} be the Lie algebra of polynomial vector fields on the affine line with degrees at least −1-1, and let U(−)U(-) denote the universal enveloping algebra. Non-noetherianity conjecture. If g\mathfrak{g} is an infinite-dimensional Lie subalgebra of W≥−1W_{\geq -1}, then U(g)U(\mathfrak{g}) is not noetherian. The conjecture is proved for graded subalgebras and for subalgebras of finite codimension, but remains open for arbitrary infinite-dimensional subalgebras of infinite codimension.

References
  1. Lucas Buzaglo, “Enveloping algebras of Krichever-Novikov algebras are not noetherian”, arXiv:2112.08828 (2022).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A 2023 paper claims to prove the conjecture for every infinite-dimensional subalgebra, but the result has not been independently verified.

The conjecture, attributed to Lucas Buzaglo, asks whether the enveloping algebra U(g)U(\mathfrak{g}) is non-noetherian for every infinite-dimensional subalgebra of the polynomial Witt algebra. The unresolved case was arbitrary subalgebras of infinite codimension.

Known results

  • Sierra and Walton (2013; revised 2014) proved non-noetherianity for the Witt algebra and its positive part.
  • Buzaglo (2021) classified infinite-dimensional subalgebras sufficiently to place each inside a canonical algebra L(f)L(f).
  • The conjecture was previously known for graded subalgebras and finite-codimension subalgebras.

2023 claimed proof

A 2023 arXiv paper states that every infinite-dimensional subalgebra LL of W1=Der⁡(k[t])\mathbb{W}_1=\operatorname{Der}(\Bbbk[t]) has finite codimension in a suitable L(f)L(f), and deduces that U(L)U(L) is not noetherian. It explicitly claims to settle Buzaglo’s conjecture, including infinite-codimension subalgebras; this claim is reported here as unverified.

Current status (as of October 2026): The full conjecture is claimed proved by a 2023 arXiv paper, but that proof remains unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.