← All problems

C*-algebraic Novak's conjecture

5 years old · traced to

Let A\mathcal{A} be a unital C*-algebra. For x∈Ax\in\mathcal{A}, define the C*-algebraic cosine by

cos⁡x=eix+e−ix2,\cos x=\frac{e^{ix}+e^{-ix}}{2},

where ex=∑m=0∞xm/m!e^x=\sum_{m=0}^{\infty}x^m/m!. Write Asa\mathcal{A}_{\mathrm{sa}} for the set of self-adjoint elements of A\mathcal{A}. C-algebraic Novak's conjecture.* For all n,d≥2n,d\geq 2 and all choices of xj=(xj,1,…,xj,d)∈Asadx_j=(x_{j,1},\dots,x_{j,d})\in\mathcal{A}_{\mathrm{sa}}^d for 1≤j≤n1\leq j\leq n, the matrix

[∏l=1d1+cos⁡(xj,l−xk,l)2−1n]1≤j,k≤n\left[\prod_{l=1}^{d}\frac{1+\cos(x_{j,l}-x_{k,l})}{2}-\frac{1}{n}\right]_{1\leq j,k\leq n}

is positive. This is a C*-algebraic analogue of Novak's conjecture; the assertion asks for positivity uniformly over unital C*-algebras and self-adjoint tuples, and its resolution is not supplied here.

References
  1. K. Mahesh Krishna, “C*-algebraic Schur product theorem, Pólya-Szegő-Rudin question and Novak's conjecture”, arXiv:2108.06662 (2021).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

The commutative case is known, while an unverified submission claims to refute the broader noncommutative conjecture with a finite-dimensional example.

Krishna formulated the conjecture in August 2021 and proved it for commutative unital C*-algebras; the general noncommutative assertion remained open.

Known results

  • The scalar Novak positivity statement holds for points in Euclidean space, and Krishna’s argument establishes the corresponding commutative C*-algebra case.

Community submission (unverified), October 28, 2026

A submitted construction claims four self-adjoint elements in M2(C)2M_2(\mathbb{C})^2 produce a Hermitian kernel with a negative quadratic form, allegedly refuting the noncommutative extension while leaving the scalar and commutative cases unchanged. This claim has not been independently assessed.

Current status (as of October 2026): The commutative case is settled, but the full noncommutative conjecture remains open because the claimed counterexample is unverified.

Sources

Solutions 1

We construct four self-adjoint inputs with two coordinates in M_2(C) for which the literal exponential-defined Novak kernel is Hermitian but not positive semidefinite. An explicit quadratic form equals cos(pisqrt(15))-3 and is at most -2. This refutes Krishna's C-algebraic extension; the scalar and commutative Novak theorems are unaffected. The matrix construction and exact failure are proved in Lean.See full solutionHide full solution

AI-assisted preprint by Myeongjin Kang, with no affiliation. Internal AI review is not external journal peer review. The accompanying Lean certificate covers the precise scoped main statement; inspect the formal endpoint, assumptions and provenance in the supporting package. Prior-art investigations are documented bounded searches, not worldwide-priority certification. Original prose is offered under CC BY 4.0 and original code/Lean under MIT; third-party rights and existing notices are preserved. The public supporting ZIP contains original proof sources and verification evidence, with bibliographic links and hashes instead of redistributed third-party source manuscripts.

Recorded prior-art/source-access limits: No prior full source-conjecture refutation found in inspected primary/citing literature. Classical radial-kernel mechanisms credited; Semantic Scholar corpus is incomplete, subscription indexes and systematic non-English search unavailable. Independent numerical precision/index-comment errors reconciled by parent addendum. No absolute worldwide priority certified.

Full paper: A Hermitian counterexample to C*-algebraic Novak positivity.

Lean proof sources and pinned verification evidence: Zenodo supporting package. MathDB has not automatically verified the attached Lean certificate.