Low-degree distinct-coordinate zero conjecture for complete symmetric polynomials

At least 5 years old · documented by

Let Fq\mathbb{F}_q be a finite field, let 3≤k≤q−23\leq k\leq q-2 (or 4≤k≤q−34\leq k\leq q-3 if qq is even), and let hh be a complete symmetric polynomial of positive degree mm in kk variables. Let Nq(h)N_q(h) count all zeros of hh in Fqk\mathbb{F}_q^k, and let Nq∗(h)N_q^*(h) count those with pairwise distinct coordinates. Low-degree distinct-coordinate zero conjecture. If 1≤m≤q−k1\leq m\leq q-k, then

Nq(h)≥Nq∗(h)≥k!.N_q(h)\geq N_q^*(h)\geq k!.

This is presented as a special case of the preceding conjecture, since the reduction condition is automatic in this degree range; the source gives no general resolution.

References

Primary source

Jun Zhang and Daqing Wan, “Rational points on complete symmetric hypersurfaces over finite fields”, arXiv:2007.11162 (2020).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Claimed progress

The conjecture remains open in its full range, with a proof known only in some parameter ranges.

The conjecture predicts at least k!k! zeros with pairwise distinct coordinates for every complete symmetric polynomial of degree mm satisfying 1≤m≤q−k1\leq m\leq q-k. The cited paper presents this as a special case of a broader conjecture; no proposer or date is identified in the retrieved sources.

Known results

  • The broader conjecture, and hence the stated low-degree case where applicable, is proved when k≤pk\leq p, with pp the characteristic of Fq\mathbb{F}_q.
  • It is also proved when k≥⌊(q+1)/2⌋k\geq \lfloor (q+1)/2\rfloor.
  • For odd qq, the paper gives bounds including Nq(h)≥6qk−3N_q(h)\geq 6q^{k-3}, but the retrieved material does not show that this settles every low-degree instance.

Current status (as of August 2026): The conjecture is settled in the cited parameter ranges k≤pk\leq p or k≥⌊(q+1)/2⌋k\geq\lfloor (q+1)/2\rfloor, but remains open for the rest of the allowed range; no complete proof or counterexample was found.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.