← All problems

The kernel conjecture for the second-kind interval transform

6 years old · traced to

Let Q⟨a,b⟩n{\mathbb Q}\langle a,b\rangle_n denote the vector space of homogeneous noncommutative abab-polynomials of degree nn, and let I2:Q⟨a,b⟩n→Q⟨a,b⟩n+1I_2:{\mathbb Q}\langle a,b\rangle_n\rightarrow {\mathbb Q}\langle a,b\rangle_{n+1} be the interval transform of the second kind. Let AQ⟨a,b⟩nA_{\mathbb Q}\langle a,b\rangle_n be the specified subspace of Q⟨a,b⟩n{\mathbb Q}\langle a,b\rangle_n.

Kernel conjecture. For each n≥1n\geq 1,

ker⁡I2=AQ⟨a,b⟩n.\ker I_2=A_{\mathbb Q}\langle a,b\rangle_n.

The conjecture identifies precisely the kernel of the second-kind interval transform, whose nontrivial kernel distinguishes it from the corresponding Tchebyshev operator framework. Its status is not resolved in the supplied source.

References
  1. Gábor Hetyei, “The type B permutohedron and the poset of intervals as a Tchebyshev transform”, arXiv:2007.07362 (2020).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A reader-submitted argument claims the conjecture is false, but this counterexample has not been independently verified.

The conjecture asserts that the second-kind interval transform has exactly the specified kernel for every degree n≥1n \ge 1. The catalogued 2020 source reported no resolution.

Community submission (unverified), November 7, 2026

A submitted argument claims a symmetric twenty-term element gives a counterexample at n=5n=5, with dim⁡ker⁡I2=13\dim \ker I_2=13 versus dim⁡A5=12\dim A_5=12, and reports computational failures at n=6,7n=6,7 while finding agreement for n≤4n \le 4. It presents the claim as a rigorous refutation, but the submission itself is unverified.

Current status (as of November 2026): The conjecture remains unsettled; a submitted counterexample at n=5n=5 is the only reported progress and is unverified.

Sources

Solutions 1

Hetyei's kernel conjecture fails at n = 5 (dim ker I_2 = 13 > 12 = dim A_5) and, computationally, at n = 6, 7; it holds for n <= 4; 347231 (Conjecture 40) fails as a remark, without separate creditSee full solutionHide full solution

A nonzero symmetric twenty-term element lies in the kernel of the degree-five second-kind interval transform. It therefore lies outside the predicted antisymmetric kernel. Exact rational elimination gives kernel dimension 13, compared with antisymmetric dimension 12. The operator uses the cited Ehrenborg–Readdy mixing rule; the paper explains the source misprint and the interpretation. Larger-degree computations and the remark concerning MathDB 347231 are distinguished from the principal certified counterexample.

Result and scope: Hetyei's kernel conjecture fails at n = 5 (dim ker I_2 = 13 > 12 = dim A_5) and, computationally, at n = 6, 7; it holds for n <= 4; 347231 (Conjecture 40) fails as a remark, without separate credit

Complete proof and verification sources: A symmetric kernel certificate for Hetyei's second-kind interval transform: a refutation of the kernel conjecture (Discrete Comput. Geom. 2024, Conjecture 39) · PDF.

The paper page includes the supplementary proof-source JSON attachment and extract_sources.py, which reconstruct the archived proof and verification sources. The linked paper gives the complete rigorous argument and specifies exactly which statements are formalized.

This is an AI-assisted research preprint. Internal review is not external journal peer review; bounded prior-art searches do not certify worldwide priority. See the paper for the source, interpretation, formalization, and trust limitations.