The linear diameter conjecture for cocircuit graphs of oriented matroids

About 6 years old · traced to

Let M\mathcal{M} be an oriented matroid of rank rr on nn elements, and let G∗(M)G^*(\mathcal{M}) be its cocircuit graph.

Linear diameter conjecture. The cocircuit graph satisfies

diam⁡(G∗(M))≤n−r+2.\operatorname{diam}(G^*(\mathcal{M})) \leq n-r+2.

This is the oldest and most ambitious challenge concerning cocircuit-graph diameters, and it resembles the Hirsch conjecture for convex polytopes. It has been disproved, by examples related to Santos's counterexamples to the Hirsch conjecture.

References

Primary source

Ilan Adler, Jesús A. De Loera, Steven Klee and Zhenyang Zhang, “Diameters of Cocircuit Graphs of Oriented Matroids: An Update”, arXiv:2006.08922 (2020).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open

The main distance bound remains open; a 2020 construction only refuted stronger versions, not this conjecture.

The conjecture asserts that every cocircuit graph has diameter at most n−r+2n-r+2. It is described as a longstanding folklore problem, but no source found a proof or counterexample to this exact bound.

Known results

  • For uniform oriented matroids, equality holds when n≤9n\leq 9, r≤3r\leq 3, or n−r≤4n-r\leq 4 (Adler, de Loera, Klee, and Zhang, 2020).
  • The cases r≤3r\leq 3 were previously proved by Babson, Finschi, Fukuda, and by Felsner et al.
  • It suffices to consider uniform oriented matroids; improved general upper bounds remain larger than n−r+2n-r+2.

2020 construction reaching the bound

Adler, de Loera, Klee, and Zhang exhibited a uniform oriented matroid of rank 2121 on 4040 elements with non-antipodal cocircuits at distance at least 21=n−r+221=n-r+2. This refutes stronger proposed bounds such as n−r+1n-r+1, but it does not disprove the linear diameter conjecture.

Current status (as of September 2026): The bound diam⁡(G∗(M))≤n−r+2\operatorname{diam}(G^*(\mathcal{M}))\leq n-r+2 is established in several restricted cases, but remains open in general, with no verified proof or counterexample found.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.