The conjecture that the Schur-degree threshold equals the Schur number
For , let be the th Schur number. Let be the least length such that every sequence in with and average satisfies . The Schur-degree threshold conjecture.
Equivalently, every sequence in of length and average satisfies . The conjecture is known for and , while the case is explicitly left open in the source.
References
- Shalom Eliahou and Pastora Revuelta, “The Schur degree of additive sets”, arXiv:2006.01502 (2020).
Progress summary
The conjecture is proved in the two smallest cases, while an unverified October submission claims counterexamples beginning in the next two cases.
Eliahou and Revuelta (2020) proposed for . They proved the cases and , leaving the general conjecture open.
Known results
- and : proved by Eliahou and Revuelta (2020).
- ; the conjectured value is (Eliahou and Revuelta, 2020).
- The paper records and .
Community submission (unverified)
Posted October 4, 2026: a submitted argument claims , using a length- sequence, and claims using a length- construction. If correct, these would refute the conjecture for and , but the submission has no independent corroboration.
Current status (as of November 2026): The cases and are settled; the claimed advances for and are unverified, and the general conjecture remains open.
Sources
Solutions 1
The conjecture predicts L(n) = S(n-1) + 1. Since S(3)=13 and S(4)=44 this predicts L(4)=14 and L(5)=45. We prove that L(4)=16 and L(5)>48 refuting the conjecture.See full solution
Theorem 1.2 (The degree-four threshold)
We have . More precisely, the sequence
has length , total , and every one of its prefixes has average at most and blocksum Schur degree at most . This refutes the case of the Conjecture and the conjectural value .
Theorem 1.3 (A degree-five interval)
We have
Let
and let be the concatenation of three copies of followed by six further entries equal to . Then has length , total , and every prefix has average at most and blocksum Schur degree at most . Hence , refuting the case of the Conjecture.
The colourings and details are written down in the attached paper.
The examples were found with the help of KI.
- Schur_L4_L5_2026-09-20.pdfOpen