The real-eigenvalue count conjecture for random sign matrices

At least 5 years old · documented by

Let MnM_n be an n×nn\times n random matrix with independent Rademacher entries.

Real-eigenvalue count conjecture. With high probability, MnM_n has Θ(n)\Theta(\sqrt n) real eigenvalues.

The analogous order is known for Gaussian matrices, but the source says that the conjecture remains open for MnM_n.

References

Primary source

Van Vu, “Recent progress in combinatorial random matrix theory”, arXiv:2005.02797 (2020).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open

No public proof or counterexample has been found, so the conjecture remains open.

The conjecture predicts that a random sign matrix has on the order of the square root of its size in real eigenvalues with high probability. The conjecture arose from a 2009 conversation involving P. M. Wood; the survey also records that Babai proposed it privately in the 1970s.

Known results

  • For Gaussian matrices, the expected number of real eigenvalues is asymptotic to 2n/π\sqrt{2n/\pi} (Edelman, Kostlan, and Shub).
  • Tao and Vu obtained asymptotic results for certain matrices with entries in {0,±1}\{0,\pm1\}, but not for Rademacher matrices.
  • Even proving that a Rademacher matrix has at least 22 real eigenvalues with high probability was recorded as open in 2016 and again in 2020.

Current status (as of August 2026): The Θ(n)\Theta(\sqrt n) conjecture remains open, and even the weaker high-probability existence of at least 22 real eigenvalues has no recorded proof here.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.