The classification conjecture for number-conserving binary cellular automata

Let the dimension dgeq1dgeq 1 be given, and consider binary cellular automata with the von Neumann neighborhood. A cellular automaton is number-conserving when it preserves the total number of occupied cells. Classification conjecture. There are exactly 4d+14d+1 number-conserving binary cellular automata: the identity rule, together with the shift and traffic rules in each of the 2d2d possible directions. The paper derives this count in dimensions up to three and presents the formula as the general classification sought for arbitrary dimension; its validity beyond the established cases remains open.

Sources & referencesView supporting material

Primary source

Barbara Wolnik, Anna Nenca, Jan M. Baetens and Bernard De Baets, “A split-and-perturb decomposition of number-conserving cellular automata”, arXiv:1901.05067 (2019).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Solved

A later theorem proves the proposed count in every dimension, so the classification is no longer open.

The conjecture asserts that binary number-conserving cellular automata with the von Neumann neighborhood are limited to the identity, shifts, and traffic rules, totaling 4d+14d+1. The earlier work established this only through dimension 33 and left higher dimensions conjectural.

Known results

  • Dimension 11: the identity, shifts, and traffic rules give the predicted count.
  • Dimension 22: exactly 99 rules.
  • Dimension 33: exactly 1313 rules, as established in earlier classification work.
  • General dimension: necessary and sufficient conservation conditions were known, but the full count was not initially derived.

2019 general classification theorem

A later paper proves that, for every dimension dd, there are exactly 4d+14d+1 such automata and that all are intrinsically one-dimensional. The result is independently restated in the PubMed record and a later survey, with no reported counterexample, proof gap, or retraction.

Current status (as of August 2026): The classification is settled for every dimension dd by the general theorem giving exactly 4d+14d+1 rules; no unresolved mathematical objection was found.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.