← All problems

Uniqueness of tangent cones at analytic-boundary points

8 years old · traced to

Let TT, Σ\Sigma, and Γ\Gamma be as in White's discreteness conjecture: TT is an area-minimizing 22-dimensional integral current in dimension m=2m=2, and Σ\Sigma and Γ\Gamma are real analytic. Let p∈Γp\in\Gamma. A tangent cone to TT at pp is a limit of blow-ups of TT centered at pp.

Tangent-cone uniqueness conjecture. There is a unique tangent cone to TT at pp.

The source presents this as an approachable subproblem that, to the authors' knowledge, had not been addressed in the literature; its status is open.

References
  1. Camillo De Lellis, Guido De Philippis, Jonas Hirsch and Annalisa Massaccesi, “On the boundary behavior of mass-minimizing integral currents”, arXiv:1809.09457 (2021).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A published theorem proves uniqueness in the Euclidean setting, but the retrieved evidence does not settle the full formulation involving Σ\Sigma.

The conjecture asks whether an area-minimizing two-dimensional current has only one tangent cone at each analytic-boundary point. The retrieved literature now proves this in important settings, but does not clearly cover every case in the stated Σ\Sigma-constrained formulation.

Known results

  • Brian White proved uniqueness for two-dimensional area-minimizing currents in the Euclidean setting; the precise year was not supplied in the retrieved sources.
  • Hirsch and Marini (2019) proved uniqueness at singular boundary points for two-dimensional almost-area-minimizing currents with C1,αC^{1,\alpha} boundary.
  • De Lellis, Nardulli, and Steinbrüchel (2023) proved uniqueness, with polynomial convergence, for Euclidean area-minimizing currents with boundary Q[ ⁣[Γ] ⁣]Q[\![\Gamma]\!] when Γ\Gamma is C1,αC^{1,\alpha}.
  • Fleschler (2024) proved uniqueness with power-rate convergence in a C2C^2 submanifold setting at boundary points of density Q/2Q/2.

2021–2024 extensions

The De Lellis–Nardulli–Steinbrüchel theorem was submitted on November 4, 2021 and published in 2023; it covers analytic boundaries when the ambient problem is Euclidean. Fleschler's October 2024 result addresses the Σ\Sigma-constrained setting but assumes density Q/2Q/2, so the complete stated conjecture remains unresolved in the retrieved record.

Current status (as of October 2026): Uniqueness is settled in the Euclidean case and in the Σ\Sigma-constrained density-Q/2Q/2 case, while the full analytic-boundary formulation remains open on the retrieved evidence.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.