The definable (p,q)(p,q)-theorem for distal theories

About 10 years old · traced to

Let M≺NM\prec N be NIP LL-structures. Let φ(x,y)\varphi(x,y) be an LML_M-formula and let b∈N∣y∣b\in N^{|y|}. Assume φ(x,b)\varphi(x,b) does not divide over MM. Chernikov–Simon conjecture. There is an LML_M-formula ψ(y)∈tp⁡(b/M)\psi(y)\in\operatorname{tp}(b/M) such that

{φ(x,b′):b′∈ψ(M)} is consistent.\{\varphi(x,b^\prime):b^\prime\in\psi(M)\}\text{ is consistent}.

This is a definable analogue of the combinatorial (p,q)(p,q)-theorem and was posed by Chernikov and Simon as a question before becoming a conjecture. The paper answers this special case affirmatively for distal NIP theories, so the conjecture is solved in the stated setting.

References

Primary source

Gareth Boxall and Charlotte Kestner, “The definable (p,q)-theorem for distal theories”, arXiv:1602.01253 (2017).

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.