The Vanishing Conjecture for homogeneous quartics

About 13 years old · traced to

Let m∈N+m\in\mathbb N_+, let C[m]=C[X1,…,Xm]{\mathbb C}^{[m]}={\mathbb C}[X_1,\ldots,X_m], and let

Δ=∂12+⋯+∂m2\Delta=\partial_1^2+\cdots+\partial_m^2

be the Laplace operator. Let f∈C[m]f\in{\mathbb C}^{[m]} be homogeneous of degree 44. Vanishing Conjecture. If Δk(fk)=0\Delta^k(f^k)=0 for all k∈N+k\in\mathbb N_+, then there exists K∈N+K\in\mathbb N_+ such that Δk(fk+1)=0\Delta^k(f^{k+1})=0 for all k≥Kk\ge K. The paper states that Zhao proved equivalence, for all dimensions, with the Jacobian Conjecture. The individual conjecture is presented as interesting and unresolved in the supplied text.

References

Primary source

Eric Edo and Arno van den Essen, “The Strong Factorial Conjecture”, arXiv:1304.3956 (2013).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Claimed solved

A 2026 preprint claims an explicit counterexample in forty variables, but the claim has not been independently verified.

The conjecture asks whether the stated Laplacian vanishing condition for a homogeneous quartic forces eventual vanishing of the next power. Zhao’s work connects this question in all dimensions with the Jacobian Conjecture.

Known results

  • Zhao (2004) proved equivalence, in all dimensions, with the Jacobian Conjecture.
  • Zhao (2004) identified the hypotheses with Hessian nilpotence of the quartic.
  • Zhao (2007) proved the conjecture under a regular-intersection condition for the projective varieties defined by PP and σ2(z)=∑izi2\sigma_2(z)=\sum_i z_i^2.

August 2026 counterexample claim

The preprint claims a homogeneous quartic in 4040 variables with 350350 monomials satisfying ΔmPm=0\Delta^mP^m=0 for every m≥1m\ge 1, but with ΔmPm+1≠0\Delta^mP^{m+1}\ne 0 for infinitely many mm. If correct, this disproves the conjecture; the supplied record contains no independent verification.

Current status (as of August 2026): The conjecture remains unverified as a theorem, with a claimed forty-variable counterexample that would disprove it if independently confirmed.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.