Even-modulus power-sum binomial congruence

From papers

Let Sm(n)=j=1n1jmS_m(n)=\sum_{j=1}^{n-1}j^m, and let kk be a positive integer. Even-modulus power-sum conjecture. For every k1k\ge 1 and every even positive integer nn, the congruence

i=0k(1+n(k+1i))(2k+22i)S2i(n)1(modn3)\sum_{i=0}^k\left(1+n(k+1-i)\right)\binom{2k+2}{2i}S_{2i}(n)\equiv -1\pmod{n^3}

holds. The source notes that division by 22 is immediate for odd nn and proposes the even-nn extension based on computations for small values of kk; no proof is given in the supplied text.

Progress summary

Open

No public discussion or published progress was found for this conjecture.

No public discussion or published progress was found.

Current status (as of August 2026): It appears open, with no recorded public activity.

Sources & referencesView supporting material

Primary source

Romeo Meštrović, “A congruence modulo n^3 involving two consecutive sums of powers and its applications”, arXiv:1211.4570 (2012).

Additional references

2 papers in this index state this conjecture (2004–2012). The statement above is taken from the most recent of them; the others are arXiv:hep-th/0404194.

Solutions 1

Proof

Write S_r(n)=Σ_{x=1}^{n−1}x^r, including S_0(n)=n−1. Fix k≥1 and an even positive n, put m=2k+2, and set A=Σ_{i=0}^k [1+n(k+1−i)]C(m,2i)S_{2i}(n). We prove A≡−1 mod n³.

The identity (2i+1)C(m,2i+1)=2(m/2−i)C(m,2i) and Pascal telescoping Σ_{r=0}^{m−1}C(m,r)S_r(n)=n^m−1 give the exact equality A+1=n^m−W/2, W=Σ_{i=0}^k C(m,2i+1)D_i, D_i=2S_{2i+1}(n)−(2i+1)nS_{2i}(n). Since m≥4, it suffices to prove 2n³|W. Note that D_0=0.

Write n=2c and f_i(x)=2x^{2i+1}−(2i+1)nx^{2i}. For i≥1, expansion at the paired arguments x and n−x gives f_i(x)+f_i(n−x)≡−n³C(2i+1,3)x^{2i−2} mod 2n³; all lower powers of n cancel, and all remaining terms contain n⁴, which is divisible by 2n³ because n is even. Therefore the weighted contribution of each pair 1≤x<c is −n³Σ_{i=1}^k C(m,2i+1)C(2i+1,3)x^{2i−2} =−n³C(m,3)Σ_{i=1}^k C(m−3,2i−2)x^{2i−2} modulo 2n³. Since m is even, C(m,3) is even, so every paired contribution vanishes modulo 2n³.

For the unpaired central argument x=c, f_i(c)=−4ic^{2i+1}. We claim 4|iC(m,2i+1) for every even m and i≥1. The binomial coefficient is even because its upper index is even and its lower index odd, proving the claim when i is even. If i is odd, use (2i+1)C(m,2i+1)=mC(m−1,2i). For 4|m the claim is immediate. Otherwise m≡2 mod4; then m−1 has binary 2's digit 0 while 2i has binary 2's digit 1, so Lucas's theorem gives C(m−1,2i) even, again proving the claim. Hence 2n³=16c³ divides C(m,2i+1)f_i(c) for every i≥1.

All paired and central contributions are therefore divisible by 2n³, proving 2n³|W. Thus n³|A+1, as required for every k≥1 and every even n. Together with the already proved odd-modulus case, the same congruence holds for all positive n.

0 endorsements
Shivam Patel ·