← All problems

Comon's conjecture on tensor rank versus symmetric rank

15 years old · documented by

Let VV be a vector space and let p∈PSdV⊲P(V⊗d)p\in\mathbb P S^dV\vartriangleleft\mathbb P(V^{\otimes d}). Let Rvd(PV)(p)R_{v_d(\mathbb P V)}(p) be the symmetric rank of pp, and let RSeg⁡(PV×⋯×PV)(p)R_{\operatorname{Seg}(\mathbb P V\times\cdots\times\mathbb P V)}(p) be its tensor rank. Comon's conjecture.

Rvd(PV)(p)=RSeg⁡(PV×⋯×PV)(p).R_{v_d(\mathbb P V)}(p)=R_{\operatorname{Seg}(\mathbb P V\times\cdots\times\mathbb P V)}(p).

The supplied text states this as Comon's conjecture and gives no resolution.

References
  1. Jarosław Buczyński, Adam Ginensky and J. M. Landsberg, “Determinantal equations for secant varieties and the Eisenbud-Koh-Stillman conjecture”, arXiv:1007.0192 (2012).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A published counterexample overturned the conjecture, although a gap in the original proof means this summary does not certify the result.

Comon's conjecture asserted that every symmetric tensor has equal tensor rank and symmetric rank. Shitov's construction disproved this over the complex numbers; analogous real counterexamples followed.

Known results

  • Equality holds when tensor rank is at most the tensor order (Qi, 2016).
  • Equality holds for symmetric rank at most 22 (Comon and collaborators, 2015).
  • Over C\mathbb{C}, equality holds for symmetric rank at most 33 (Comon and collaborators, 2015).
  • Further positive cases include tangential Veronese tensors and several bounded-rank families (Alex et al., 2018).

2018–2026 counterexamples and repair history

Shitov's 2018 example has format 800×800×800800\times800\times800, tensor rank 903903, and symmetric rank at least 904904. A 2024 erratum identified a gap in the published proof, while a repaired construction was circulated. Shitov later gave a real counterexample, and Seigal and Wang reported an order-66 real example in 2023. A 2026 preprint claims a smaller rational example with ranks 5555 and 5656, but that claim is unverified.

Current status (as of October 2026): The original equality conjecture is refuted by claimed complex and real counterexamples, while the proof repair and the 2026 smaller example remain unverified; the border-rank analogue and minimality questions remain open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.