Poincaré conjecture
Let be a closed, connected topological -manifold: a compact Hausdorff space without boundary in which every point has a neighborhood homeomorphic to . Suppose that is simply connected, that is, every loop in can be continuously contracted to a point; equivalently, the fundamental group is trivial.
Poincaré conjecture. Every such is homeomorphic to the three-sphere
This is the formulation in Milnor's official Clay problem description [1]. By Moise's theorem every topological -manifold has a smooth structure, unique up to diffeomorphism, so the statement is equivalent to its smooth version: every closed, simply connected smooth -manifold is diffeomorphic to [12]. It is now a theorem, proved by Perelman in 2002–2003 using Hamilton's Ricci flow [3, 4, 5].
Background
Poincaré first asked whether a closed -manifold with the homology of must be , and then found a counterexample: the Poincaré homology sphere, whose fundamental group is the binary icosahedral group of order . In 1904 he asked instead whether trivial fundamental group suffices [2]. The question became the central problem of three-dimensional topology. Thurston's geometrization conjecture, which describes every closed orientable -manifold as built from pieces carrying one of eight model geometries, contains it as a special case [1].
The analogous statement in higher dimensions — a closed -manifold homotopy equivalent to is homeomorphic to — was proved by Smale for [10] and by Freedman for [11]. In dimension a closed, simply connected manifold is automatically homotopy equivalent to , so this is the same statement. In the smooth category the four-dimensional case is still open: see the smooth four-dimensional Poincaré conjecture.
Equivalent formulations
Let be a simply connected, closed -manifold, where closed means compact without boundary. Poincaré conjecture. is homeomorphic to the -sphere . The conjecture is a purely topological statement, but it was proved using the Riemannian metric structure on smooth manifolds.
source: Aoran Chen, “A Variational Approach to the Yamabe Problem: Conformal Transformations and Scalar Curvature on Compact Riemannian Manifolds”, arXiv:2309.02397 (2024).
References
- J. Milnor, "The Poincaré conjecture", in J. Carlson, A. Jaffe and A. Wiles (eds.), The Millennium Prize Problems, Clay Math. Inst. and AMS (2006). Clay problem page
- H. Poincaré, "Cinquième complément à l'Analysis situs", Rend. Circ. Mat. Palermo 18 (1904), 45–110.
- G. Perelman, "The entropy formula for the Ricci flow and its geometric applications", preprint (2002). arXiv:math/0211159
- G. Perelman, "Ricci flow with surgery on three-manifolds", preprint (2003). arXiv:math/0303109
- G. Perelman, "Finite extinction time for the solutions to the Ricci flow on certain three-manifolds", preprint (2003). arXiv:math/0307245
- R. S. Hamilton, "Three-manifolds with positive Ricci curvature", J. Differential Geom. 17 (1982), 255–306.
- J. Morgan and G. Tian, Ricci Flow and the Poincaré Conjecture, Clay Math. Monographs 3, AMS (2007). arXiv:math/0607607
- B. Kleiner and J. Lott, "Notes on Perelman's papers", Geom. Topol. 12 (2008), 2587–2855. arXiv:math/0605667
- H.-D. Cao and X.-P. Zhu, "A complete proof of the Poincaré and geometrization conjectures — application of the Hamilton–Perelman theory of the Ricci flow", Asian J. Math. 10 (2006), 165–492. arXiv:math/0612069
- S. Smale, "Generalized Poincaré's conjecture in dimensions greater than four", Ann. of Math. 74 (1961), 391–406.
- M. H. Freedman, "The topology of four-dimensional manifolds", J. Differential Geom. 17 (1982), 357–453.
- E. E. Moise, "Affine structures in 3-manifolds. V. The triangulation theorem and Hauptvermutung", Ann. of Math. 56 (1952), 96–114.
- Clay Mathematics Institute, Poincaré conjecture (prize announcement, 2010).
- Wikipedia, Poincaré conjecture.
Source: Wikipedia
Progress summary
Perelman’s work settled the century-old question: every closed, simply connected three-dimensional space is a three-sphere.
Henri Poincaré posed the question in 1904. Grigoriy Perelman answered it in 2002–2003 through Hamilton’s Ricci-flow program, as part of the proof of geometrization.
Known results
- Hamilton, 1982: introduced Ricci flow and proved the positive-Ricci-curvature case.
- Perelman, 2002–2003: proved noncollapsing, controlled surgery, and finite-time extinction, yielding the conjecture.
- Kleiner–Lott, 2008; Morgan–Tian, 2007; Cao–Zhu, 2006: supplied detailed expositions and complete proof accounts.
Community submission (unverified), November 6, 2026
A submitted exposition recapitulates Perelman’s proof, including Ricci flow with surgery, finite extinction, and the reconstruction of the original manifold from the surgery record. It presents no new result.
Current status (as of November 2026): Perelman’s theorem settles the stated conjecture, and detailed independent accounts support the proof; no part of the problem remains open.
Solutions 7
Exposition: a 130-page article and a 50:28 narrated film on the Poincare conjecture, the Hamilton-Perelman proof by Ricci flow with surgery, and the mathematical organization of its Lean formalization. The opening is for general readers; later sections explain the geometry, width argument, surgery history, reconstruction and formal statements.See full solution
Every Loop Shrinks: the Poincaré conjecture and its Lean formalization
This is an exposition of the Hamilton–Perelman proof and the mathematical organization of its Lean formalization. The attached article and companion film begin with the question about shrinking loops, tell the geometric argument, and explain the objects and estimates behind the formal statements.
Article: Ricci Flow with Surgery and the Poincaré Conjecture: An Exposition of a Lean Formalization, by Yuan Liao (November 11, 2026; 130 pages). The complete preprint is attached as poincare_exposition.pdf.
Video: . The description includes thirteen chapter timestamps. Narration is synthetic; surfaces, graphs and motions are schematic illustrations rather than numerical Ricci-flow simulations.
A route through the material
The opening sections are written for the general reader: what the conjecture says, why a sphere and a solid ball differ, the history of the problem, the idea of Ricci flow with surgery, and what it means for a computer to check a proof.
The rest of the article addresses readers with geometry and analysis in mind. It follows smooth Ricci flow, noncollapsing and singularity models, canonical neighborhoods, the topology of a cut-and-cap operation, the assembly of a finite surgery history, extinction from loop-family width, and reconstruction from the recorded surgeries. Moise's theorem then returns from smooth manifolds to the topological statement. Appendices give the declaration dictionary, dependency diagrams and an index of Lean names.
The film follows the same route through thirteen chapters, from loops to the reconstruction endgame. The article supplies definitions, estimates, citations and formal statement references behind the pictures.
Formalization and attribution
The collaborative formalization is by Ziyang Qin, Yuan Liao, Ayush Khaitan, and Bennett Chow, in that order. Qin and Liao contributed equally. The exposition discusses DifferentialGeometry v0.1.4, commit 788efe9, using Lean/Mathlib v4.35.0-rc3.
The underlying proof is the Hamilton–Perelman proof of the classical conjecture. This submission explains that proof and its formal organization; the exposition and illustrations are not an independent kernel replay or axiom audit. A displayed command such as #print axioms poincare_conjecture is an instruction for checking the pinned source, not a reproduced audit result.
The original formalization paper is A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture. The new exposition is supplied directly as the attached preprint.
Original MathDB source record
This post originally linked the MathDB-specific source revision, adapted from DifferentialGeometry v0.1.3, commit 7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3. That adapter uses Lean 4.33.1 and the problem's frozen Mathlib revision 0df444a360eaa60ab8c11dca51a86af692955474; its entry point is Submission.solution : Problem.Target in Submission.lean, with 14,234 helper modules.
Those frozen adapter versions and the v0.1.4 release discussed in the exposition are different source targets. The original validation reports and hashes remain under verification/ in the linked immutable revision. They have not been rerun for this expository update. The original post reported that MathDB rejected its approximately 55 MB repository attachment under the repository-download size limit; that historical ingestion issue is separate from the attached article and video.
Lean verifiedA Lean formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman proof of the Poincaré conjecture by Ziyang Qin, Yuan Liao, Ayush Khaitan, and Bennett Chow, submitted from the v0.1.3 MathDB-specific fork with the requested verifier compatibility fixes.See full solution
This is a new submission for MathDB's updated large-repository verifier, using the native mathdb-poincare-v0.1.3 branch. The root Submission.lean exports Submission.solution : Problem.Target and imports the unchanged saved statement FtpEvalBench.YPoincare_poincare_conjecture.
The project is a fork of Ziyang Qin's DifferentialGeometry repository, created specifically for MathDB. The original formalization is described in A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture, by Ziyang Qin, Yuan Liao, Ayush Khaitan, and Bennett Chow; Qin and Liao contributed equally. Original source attribution and licenses are preserved.
The development starts from v0.1.3, commit 7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3, and uses Lean 4.33.1 with Mathlib 0df444a360eaa60ab8c11dca51a86af692955474. The adapter derives compactness and simple connectivity from MathDB's homotopy-equivalence hypothesis and applies the topological Poincaré theorem proved in the included development. The full mathematical proof is included in the repository's native library. The homotopy-sphere compactness bridge is backported from v0.1.4 for this frozen environment.
The compatibility update requested for MathDB removes the five diagnostic run_cmd axiom-check blocks in the imported proof closure. It also changes completeInst to a private theorem and connectedCanonicalMetricCompactness to a private definition, preserving both bodies. The root entry point and frozen target are unchanged.
The submitted revision is 9f65eaf95b9ff5f1b39cfb2d2d24e51aed891568. Targeted local checks on October 26, 2026 compiled all seven edited modules and the entry point against cached dependencies. Submission.solution reports only propext, Classical.choice, and Quot.sound; the check report records the scope and results. These checks are separate from a clean rebuild and a new full kernel replay. MathDB's own verification status is displayed with this submission.
Exposition (not a new solution) for the Exposition category, JSP-000007. An 8-page essay and an 8.6-minute narrated video on the Hamilton–Perelman proof and its Lean formalization: Ricci flow, noncollapsing, canonical neighbourhoods and surgery, finite extinction via the width (integrated explicitly), the topology endgame, and exactly what MathDB's Lean verification certifies. Claims are tagged by provenance.See full solution
Exposition, not a new solution. Submitted for the Exposition category of the MathDB × Justin Sun Prize pilot (JSP-000007).
An essay and a narrated video explaining Perelman's proof and the Lean formalization by Qin, Liao, Khaitan and Chow (arXiv:2609.33842), whose MathDB-adapted revision 9f65eaf9 is Lean verified on this page.
What it covers
- Ricci flow as a heat equation; the round sphere ; the barrier .
- Perelman's entropy and -noncollapsing, Hamilton–Ivey pinching, -solutions, canonical neighbourhoods, surgery.
- Finite extinction through the topological width : integrating gives an explicit (matching
extinctionThreshold). - Connected sums, van Kampen, and Moise smoothing to conclude .
- The Lean endpoints, the library's scale, a map from proof steps to Lean names, and what the MathDB verification record certifies.
Every statement is tagged [Literature], [Formalization], [Check] or [Heuristic]. All mathematics and formalization are due to the cited authors; this is exposition only.
Fixed version (v1.0, 29 Oct 2026), essay + video: https://github.com/Thanh-Van-2001/poincare-ricci-flow-exposition/releases/tag/v1.0
Prepared with AI assistance (Claude); the narration uses a synthesized voice.
Exposition (not a new solution) for the Exposition category, JSP-000007. A short essay and a 4:17 narrated video that explain the Poincaré conjecture and the Hamilton–Perelman proof to people with no advanced mathematics. Claims are tagged by origin. We report the Lean formalization and do not vouch for it.See full solution
Exposition, not a new solution. Submitted for the Exposition category of the MathDB × Justin Sun Prize pilot (JSP-000007).
Author: @jhonsu777 (2xrqx82e2@mozmail.com). Prepared with AI assistance (Claude, Anthropic). All the mathematics is due to the cited authors.
Aim. To make this theorem understandable to anyone, using a rope, an ant and a shape that heals itself, while keeping the claims accurate.
What it covers
- The rope test and what the conjecture asks.
- Why dimension three took longer than higher dimensions.
- Ricci flow, necks, and surgery.
- Perelman's control of the process, and finite extinction.
- Why running the flow backward can only rebuild a sphere.
- What a formal proof adds, and what it does not.
What we checked. Symbolic checks of the round three-sphere under Ricci flow, and of the arithmetic behind the width argument. We also confirmed the form of the Colding–Minicozzi inequality in their paper.
Limits. We did not compile the Lean formalization by Qin, Liao, Khaitan and Chow, or audit its statement. We report what its authors state and what MathDB displays. We did not read the classical papers line by line, and this exposition has not been independently reviewed.
Materials
- Fixed version: v1.0, 2026-11-04, commit
7eabeba9add2dc3eb042acb03f9de38a67484660 - Repository: https://github.com/jhonsu01/poincare-shape-exposition
- Essay: https://github.com/jhonsu01/poincare-shape-exposition/releases/download/v1.0/essay_en.pdf
- Video:
- Sources: listed in the essay's references. Licenses and credits are in
NOTICE.md.
Exposition - an 11-page essay and two short videos that explain Perelman's proof of the Poincaré conjecture by Ricci flow with surgery to readers who know calculus but not differential geometrySee full solution
Exposition for JSP-000007: Poincaré conjecture.
Author: Zinan Xing. Date: November 4, 2026.
Exposition essay: https://github.com/neoskyz/poincare-conjecture-exposition/blob/v1.0/poincare-conjecture-exposition.pdf
Videos:
V2, animation flow + music, no narration:
V1, narrated (author's voice):
Sources:
- G. Perelman, The entropy formula for the Ricci flow and its geometric applications, Ricci flow with surgery on three-manifolds and Finite extinction time for the solutions to the Ricci flow on certain three-manifolds;
- Milnor's Clay problem statement;
- the Lean formalization by Qin, Liao, Khaitan and Chow (repo, commit
f14e302a; MathDB submission fork, commit9f65eaf9).
Contributions: A reader-level narrative of the Ricci-flow proof, a clause-by-clause check of the Lean statement against Milnor's text, and two companion videos.
(The essay, figures and videos were prepared with the assistance of AI.)
A visual guide to the Poincaré conjecture: how Ricci flow and surgery reveal the shape of a three-dimensional space. Includes a 10-page essay, a 7-minute narrated video, diagrams and worked exercises. For curious readers, with optional details for mathematics students.See full solution
Exposition for JSP-000007 · David Liu · Version 1.1
How can a process that ends with an empty manifold tell us what that manifold looked like in the first place? That question is the starting point for this essay and video about the Poincaré conjecture.
I follow the proof through the record of the changes made during Ricci flow with surgery. Keeping track of the cuts and the pieces removed lets us work backward and see why a closed, simply connected three-manifold must be a three-sphere.
The explanation starts with familiar shapes and loops before introducing the geometry. Along the way, it covers:
- Why each hypothesis matters, and why shrinking a loop is different from untying a knot.
- What Ricci flow does to a round sphere, with a worked calculation.
- How the two types of sphere surgery change the topology, illustrated with diagrams.
- How finite extinction and the surgery record fit together to finish the argument.
- What the Lean statement says and what formal verification can tell us.
The main story is for curious readers; optional calculus panels and worked exercises offer more detail for mathematics students.
Attached: a 10-page essay, a 7:07 narrated video with English captions and 20 chapters, and the narration transcript. All three are version 1.1, prepared on 6 November 2026.
This is an exposition of established mathematics, submitted for the Exposition category. The mathematics comes from Hamilton’s Ricci-flow program and Perelman’s proof, with detailed accounts by the authors cited below. The Lean formalization discussed here is by Ziyang Qin, Yuan Liao, Ayush Khaitan and Bennett Chow. The essay includes the exact source revisions and explains the limits of the verification evidence; I have not independently rebuilt the full formalization.
Prepared with AI assistance in research, writing, diagrams and video production.
References
- Milnor, The Poincaré Conjecture, §1.
- Hamilton, Three-manifolds with positive Ricci curvature, Theorem 1.1.
- Perelman, Ricci flow with surgery and Finite extinction time.
- Hatcher, Algebraic Topology and Notes on Basic 3-Manifold Topology.
- Kleiner–Lott, Notes on Perelman's Papers, §3.
- Morgan–Tian, Ricci Flow and the Poincaré Conjecture, with the 2015 correction.
- Frozen MathDB target, submitted adapter and contributor validation record.
Exposition for readers with undergraduate topology and analysis: a 21-page article and a 10-minute narrated film (4K) on the Poincaré conjecture, the Hamilton–Perelman proof by Ricci flow with surgery, and exactly what the verified Lean formalization certifies. Fixed version v1.0.0, public 2026-11-06.See full solution
Category. Exposition, by Yao Xu (@cadamcat). The mathematics is Hamilton's and Perelman's, and the formalization is by Qin, Liao, Khaitan and Chow; I am an author of neither.
Readers. The article assumes undergraduate topology and analysis. Sections 3–6 also use some Riemannian geometry: curvature, and geodesic balls and their volumes. The film follows the same plan in less detail.
Materials (fixed version).
- Repository: https://github.com/cadamcat/poincare-exposition, tag
v1.0.0= commitaac4487cd997cbce7e29b04898e1ef820c4ac2e8. - Release: https://github.com/cadamcat/poincare-exposition/releases/tag/v1.0.0, with three files:
- the film
poincare-exposition-film-4k.mp4(10 min 3 s, 3840×2160, subtitles in the picture); - the article
poincare-exposition-article.pdf(21 pages); - the narration
poincare-exposition-narration.flac, from which the film is rebuilt.
- the film
- Attached to this post: the article (PDF) and the film, with the same content as the release files.
- Public date: the repository was created on 2026-11-06 at 17:24 UTC; this fixed version (tag and release v1.0.0) was published on 2026-11-06 at 21:23 UTC. Archived by Software Heritage: snapshot
swh:1:snp:6eaf00b8cfcc97d13870fcede882c358be09604f(save request 2621368). - Licences: CC BY 4.0 for the article, film and script; Apache-2.0 for code.
What it covers.
- The question: three-manifolds, simple connectivity, Poincaré's 1904 question and his homology-sphere example, the higher-dimensional cases, Moise's theorem, and geometrization.
- Ricci flow and Hamilton's programme: the round-sphere computation, Hamilton's 1982 theorem (spherical space forms), and the problem of singularities.
- Perelman's 𝒲-entropy under its coupled evolution, no local collapsing, and reduced volume.
- Ancient κ-solutions and the canonical neighbourhood theorem, with the complete list of model neighbourhoods, including RP³-caps and nearly round closed components.
- Surgery: the δ-cutoff construction, the standard solution, and necks that do not separate (S²×S¹).
- Finite extinction:
- Perelman's loop width and its inequality, with the Gauss–Bonnet step written out;
- why the width cannot rise at a surgery;
- why one deadline holds for every component: the ancestor chain back to the initial manifold;
- the explicit extinction time T*;
- the Colding–Minicozzi route with its own constants (−4π, 16π), kept separate from Perelman's (−2π, 8π).
- The topological conclusion, and the status of the proof: the 2006 verifications and the 2010 Clay prize.
- The Lean formalization:
- the frozen MathDB statement read clause by clause, including why compactness need not be assumed and why the Hausdorff hypothesis is needed;
- how
Submission.solutionreaches the Milnor form, Moise smoothing and the smooth theorem; - the axioms;
- a three-part trust statement, and what the check does not certify.
Proved, Lean-checked and heuristic are kept apart.
- Every claim of the article is listed in
article/CLAIMS.md, with its source (paper and section, Lean declaration, or record) and its status:- proved: published, or Perelman's preprints as verified by the 2006 expositions;
- Lean;
- heuristic.
- Every film beat carries the same status on screen.
- The exposition itself has not been peer reviewed, and says so.
- We did not rebuild the formal proof or audit the library's internal definitions, and the article says so.
Sources.
article/SOURCES.mdgives every citation with a verified locator: Perelman's three preprints; Kleiner–Lott, Morgan–Tian (with the 2015 correction) and Cao–Zhu; Colding–Minicozzi; Hamilton; Milnor's Clay description; the formalization paper and repository, at their pinned revisions.- The formalization paper's pages shown in the film are CC BY 4.0, and the quoted Lean source is Apache-2.0. Both are credited in
THIRD_PARTY.md.
Original contributions.
- The exposition itself: the selection and order of the material, the explanations, the figures and the film. The ancestor-chain account in §6.3 follows the formalization paper (§2) and Morgan–Tian (§18.3).
- Our clause-by-clause reading of
Problem.Target, including how the formal proof obtains compactness from the homotopy equivalence (§§8.2–8.3). - The trust analysis: what must be trusted, and why errors in internal definitions cannot make a false final statement provable (§8.6).
No new mathematics is claimed.
This entry appears to be misclassified as open. The Poincaré conjecture was proved by Grigori Perelman in 2002–2003, and this page’s own References section already states “Status: solved.” A detailed account of the proof is available in Morgan and Tian, Ricci Flow and the Poincaré Conjecture: https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0607607
Could the status be updated from open to solved?