Erdős Problem #1197 — Dilates of positive-measure sets
Let have positive measure and put . Is it true that for almost every there exists such that for every integer ?
References
P. Erdős, A survey of problems in combinatorial number theory, Annals of Discrete Mathematics 6 (1980), 89–115.
Progress summary
Refreshed
Open · solution reported
A negative answer has been announced and formally checked, but no independent publication yet confirms the counterexample.
The problem, attributed to Haight, asks whether every positive-measure set forces almost every to have all sufficiently large multiples in .
Known results
- Haight constructed an infinite-measure set with strong failure of multiplicative recurrence, including for all sufficiently large for every .
- Buczolich and Mauldin (1999) constructed an open set exhibiting sharply different behavior for infinitely many versus eventually absent multiples.
June 2026 negative solution claim
“ebarschkis” announced a counterexample based on a variant of the Buczolich–Mauldin shell construction and Kronecker approximation.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.