Erdős Problem #603 — Let be a family of countably infinite sets such that for all .
Let be a family of countably infinite sets such that for all . Find the smallest cardinal such that can always be coloured with at most colours so that no is monochromatic.
References
Primary source
Additional references
UnsolvedMath, Erdős Problems set, ULAM AI, licensed CC BY 4.0.
Progress summary
A recent unverified construction claims that no fixed number of colours works for arbitrary families, while families with only countably many members can be handled with two colours.
The problem asks for the least uniform colouring bound preventing every member of a family of countably infinite sets from being monochromatic when pairwise intersections avoid size . The discussion distinguishes arbitrary-sized families from families indexed by a countable set.
Known results
- Komjáth showed that countably many colours suffice under the related condition that pairwise intersections are not of size .
April–July 2026 claimed counterexample
A forum discussion attributes a construction to GPT 5.4 Pro, prompted by Przemek Chojecki, using countably infinite complete subgraphs and the Erdős–Rado theorem. It claims that arbitrary-sized families admit no uniform set-sized colour bound, while the countable-family interpretation has exact answer . The construction has no independent verification or published proof in the retrieved sources.
Current status (as of September 2026): The claimed arbitrary-family refutation and the claimed countable-family answer remain unverified; Komjáth's countable-colour upper bound under the related intersection condition is the only recorded classical result.
Sources
- erdosproblems.com
- erdosproblems.com
- huggingface.co
- erdosproblems.com
- combinatorica.hu
- mathoverflow.net
- quantamagazine.org
- unsolvedmath.com
- renyi.hu
- quantamagazine.org
- quantamagazine.org
- arxiv.org
- arxiv.org
- ar5iv.labs.arxiv.org
- arxiv.org
- arxiv.org
- mathstodon.xyz
- mathstodon.xyz
- mathstodon.xyz
- mathstodon.xyz
- mathstodon.xyz
- quantamagazine.org
- cdn.openai.com
- quantamagazine.org
- cdn.openai.com
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.