Erdős Problem #267 — Let and be the Fibonacci sequence. Let be an infinite sequence with . Must be irrational?
Let and be the Fibonacci sequence. Let be an infinite sequence with . Must be irrational?
References
Primary source
Additional references
UnsolvedMath, Erdős Problems set, ULAM AI, licensed CC BY 4.0.
Progress summary
A formal proof is claimed but not publicly verifiable; the problem remains open in the range below the known threshold.
Erdős and Graham posed the question in : whether every sufficiently lacunary reciprocal Fibonacci sum is irrational.
Known results
- Badea proved irrationality for in .
- Good () and Bicknell–Hoggatt () found .
- André-Jeannin proved irrational in .
- Transcendence holds for arbitrary sequences when ; this strengthens earlier bounds.
AlphaProof claim
A formalization comment says “Formal proof provided by AlphaProof,” but the theorem remains marked open and contains sorry; no completed proof or independent mathematical artifact is available.
Current status (as of March 2026): Irrationality is settled for and transcendence for , while the original range remains open; the AlphaProof solution claim is unverified.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.