Log-concavity of codimension-three pure O-sequences

About 4 years old · traced to

For a pure O-sequence h=(h0,…,he)h=(h_0,\ldots,h_e) of codimension three and type two, is hi2≥hi−1hi+1h_i^2\geq h_{i-1}h_{i+1} for every interior index ii?

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Claimed solved

The problem is still officially open, although an unverified AI-generated proof claims to settle it.

The question asks whether every pure OO-sequence of codimension 33 and type 22 is log-concave. The question arose from earlier work of Iarrobino, and the 2022 literature identifies this as the principal unresolved case.

Known results

  • Log-concavity holds for pure OO-sequences of type 11.
  • Non-log-concave examples exist for (r,t)=(3,4)(r,t)=(3,4) and for all r≥4r\geq 4 with 2≤t≤r+12\leq t\leq r+1.
  • All level Hilbert functions of codimension 22, and all Gorenstein Hilbert functions of codimension 33, are settled cases.

May 2026 AI-generated proof claim

A newly reported AI-driven formal-proof-search agent claims a proof for the codimension-33, type-22 case, using a reformulation of the Hilbert function and case analysis of second-difference inequalities. The claim is not independently verified by a published proof or other corroborating source.

Current status (as of May 2026): the case remains unresolved in the literature, despite an unverified claim of an AI-generated proof.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.