← All problems

Gaussian completely monotone conjecture

13 years old · traced to

Conjecture 1 (Gaussian Completely Monotone Conjecture). Let Yt=X+ZtY_t=X+Z_t, where XX and ZtZ_t are independent and Zt∼N(0,t)Z_t\sim\mathcal{N}(0,t). Then I(Yt)I(Y_t) is completely monotone in tt; equivalently, for every integer n≥0n\geq 0 and every t>0t>0, (−1)ndndtnI(Yt)≥0(-1)^n\frac{d^n}{dt^n}I(Y_t)\geq 0.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An explicit one-dimensional counterexample now shows that the conjecture is false, although several important restricted cases remain valid.

Cheng and Geng introduced the Gaussian completely monotone conjecture in 2015: all heat-flow entropy derivatives should have the predicted alternating signs. The unrestricted assertion is now disproved by a finite-support probability measure on R\mathbb{R}; the conjecture therefore does not hold in every dimension or derivative order.

Known results

  • Cheng and Geng (2015): dimension 11, orders m≤4m\le 4.
  • Costa: every dimension for orders m≤2m\le 2.
  • Guo, Yuan, and Gao: dimensions d≤4d\le 4 for m=3m=3, and dimension d=2d=2 for m=4m=4.
  • For log-concave initial measures: every dimension and m≤5m\le 5.

May 2026 counterexample

An arXiv preprint gives 0.36<Hμ(5)(1/3)<0.370.36<H_\mu^{(5)}(1/3)<0.37 for an explicit one-dimensional measure, violating the required sign at order m=5m=5. It also claims failure for some log-concave measure at an unspecified order m≥6m\ge 6. The paper credits GPT-5.5 Pro with finding the explicit counterexample.

Current status (as of May 2026): The unrestricted conjecture is settled negatively by an explicit order-55 one-dimensional counterexample; lower-order and log-concave cases through m≤5m\le 5 remain valid, while further restricted behavior remains to be determined.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.