← All problems

Reiner–Rhoades q-Ehrhart conjecture

For every lattice polytope PP, the associated qq-Ehrhart series EP(q,t)E_P(q,t) is a rational function and satisfies the corresponding qq-reciprocity relation; moreover, the associated harmonic algebra is finitely generated, together with the further structural properties asserted in the Reiner–Rhoades formulation.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An August 2026 preprint claims the conjecture is proved for a special family related to hypersimplices, but the general conjecture remains unsettled.

Reiner and Rhoades formulated the conjecture in July 2024, predicting rationality and reciprocity for certain graded lattice-point series, together with finite-generation and related properties of a harmonic algebra.

Known results

  • Cavey (August 2025) gave lattice-triangle counterexamples to finite generation of the harmonic algebra, disproving that part for general lattice polytopes.
  • The same work left rationality of the qq-Ehrhart series open.
  • A March 2026 preprint claims the rationality, reciprocity, finite-generation, and Cohen–Macaulay assertions for unimodular zonotopes.

August 2026 hypersimplex-related result

A preprint reports generators for the orbit harmonics ideal and the required rationality and reciprocity statements for hypersimplex-related polytopes, claiming a resolution in that restricted class. The result is not yet peer reviewed, and no source establishes the conjecture for arbitrary lattice polytopes.

Current status (as of August 2026): The conjecture is claimed solved for hypersimplex-related polytopes, while finite generation is false for general lattice polytopes and the general rationality question remains open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.