← All problems

Brezis Open Problem 2.2

Let B1⊂R2B_1\subset\mathbb{R}^2 be the unit disk, let ε>0\varepsilon>0, and define the Ginzburg--Landau energy Eε(u)=∫B1(12∣∇u∣2+14ε2(1−∣u∣2)2) dxE_\varepsilon(u)=\int_{B_1}\left(\frac12|\nabla u|^2+\frac{1}{4\varepsilon^2}(1-|u|^2)^2\right)\,dx for u∈H1(B1;R2)u\in H^1(B_1;\mathbb{R}^2). Let Uε(x)=fε(∣x∣) x/∣x∣U_\varepsilon(x)=f_\varepsilon(|x|)\,x/|x| be the degree-one radial solution of the planar Ginzburg--Landau equation with boundary trace Uε∣∂B1(x)=xU_\varepsilon|_{\partial B_1}(x)=x. Is UεU_\varepsilon a global minimizer of EεE_\varepsilon among all u∈H1(B1;R2)u\in H^1(B_1;\mathbb{R}^2) satisfying u∣∂B1(x)=xu|_{\partial B_1}(x)=x?

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An unrefereed manuscript claims to settle Brezis’s question for every parameter value, but the proof has not yet been independently verified.

Brezis asked whether the degree-11 radial Ginzburg–Landau solution is the global minimizer in the unit disk with boundary data u(x)=xu(x)=x. The question was first numbered Open Problem 66 and later Open Problem 2.22.2.

Known results

  • Strict convexity settles ε≥λ1−1/2\varepsilon\geq\lambda_1^{-1/2}.
  • Pacard–Rivière proved that, for sufficiently small ε\varepsilon, the radial solution is the only critical point.
  • These results left intermediate values of ε\varepsilon unresolved.

August 2026 claimed solution

Hong-Ge Chen, Yong Liu, Juncheng Wei, and Wen Yang claim that, for every ε>0\varepsilon>0, Uε(r,θ)=fε(r)eiθU_\varepsilon(r,\theta)=f_\varepsilon(r)e^{i\theta} globally minimizes the energy among maps on B1(0)B_1(0) with boundary value u(x)=xu(x)=x, uniquely up to almost-everywhere equality. Their argument compares with the whole-plane vortex and decomposes the difference into nonnegative Fourier-mode contributions. No referee report, independent verification, counterexample, or withdrawal was found.

Current status (as of August 2026): The all-parameter minimization is claimed in an unrefereed version-11 preprint, while the claim remains unverified; the result is limited to the disk and the stated boundary condition.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.