← All problems

Shank–Wehlau–Broer conjecture on modular invariant rings

4 years old · traced to

Let GG be a finite pp-group acting linearly on a finite-dimensional vector space VV over a field of characteristic p>0p>0. Set S=Sym⁡V∗S=\operatorname{Sym}V^* and let SGS^G denote the invariant subring. Regard SS as an SGS^G-module.

Shank–Wehlau–Broer conjecture. If SGS^G is a direct summand of SS as an SGS^G-module, then SGS^G is a polynomial ring.

This conjecture concerns the converse to the fact that a polynomial invariant ring is a direct summand of its symmetric algebra. It is attributed to R. J. Shank and D. L. Wehlau, and was reformulated by A. Broer; the supplied text does not state whether it has been resolved.

References
  1. Manoj Kummini and Mandira Mondal, “On polynomial invariant rings in modular invariant theory”, arXiv:2210.05945 (2024).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

The conjecture remains open, but several substantial families of group actions are now settled in its favor.

Shank and Wehlau formulated the assertion that a direct-summand invariant ring must be polynomial; Broer reformulated it using the transfer condition. No date for the original formulation is supplied.

Known results

  • Broer proved the conjecture for abelian pp-groups; Elmer and Sezer handled further classes.
  • The conjecture holds for generalized Nakajima groups (2021).
  • It holds over Fp\mathbb{F}_p when dim⁡FpV=4\dim_{\mathbb{F}_p}V=4, and when ∣G∣=p3|G|=p^3 (2022).
  • It holds for permutation subgroups; in particular, for finite pp-groups acting by permutations (2025).

October 2022 partial confirmation

A paper proved the two additional cases above and showed that the Hilbert ideal is a complete intersection when dim⁡VG≥dim⁡V−2\dim V^G\geq\dim V-2, yielding the result in dimensions at most 33. It presents these as partial progress, not a full resolution; no verified full proof or counterexample was found.

Community submission (unverified)

A submitted manuscript claims a counterexample to a different transfer-quotient degree-bound conjecture for C2×C2C_2\times C_2 over F2\mathbb{F}_2; it does not address the Shank--Wehlau--Broer implication.

Current status (as of August 2026): The conjecture is proved for several special classes, but remains open for arbitrary finite pp-groups and representations; no verified full proof or counterexample is recorded.

Sources

Solutions 1

This solution needs a summarySee full solutionHide full solution

\documentclass[11pt]{article}

\usepackage[T1]{fontenc} \usepackage{lmodern} \usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,mathtools} \usepackage[margin=1in]{geometry} \usepackage{microtype} \usepackage[hidelinks]{hyperref} \usepackage{enumitem}

\newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section] \newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition} \newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma} \newtheorem{corollary}[theorem]{Corollary} \theoremstyle{definition} \newtheorem{definition}[theorem]{Definition} \newtheorem{example}[theorem]{Example} \theoremstyle{remark} \newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark}

\newcommand{\kk}{\mathbb{F}_2} \newcommand{\Tr}{\operatorname{Tr}} \newcommand{\Br}{\operatorname{Br}} \newcommand{\rad}{\operatorname{rad}} \newcommand{\Sym}{\operatorname{Sym}} \newcommand{\Span}{\operatorname{span}} \newcommand{\supp}{\operatorname{supp}} \newcommand{\one}{\mathbf{1}}

\title{A Counterexample to the Degree-Bound Conjecture\ for Transfer Quotients of Modular Invariant Rings} \author{} \date{}

\begin{document} \maketitle

\begin{abstract} We give an explicit counterexample to the conjecture that, for a finite group GG in characteristic p>0p>0, the transfer quotient

k[V]G/∑Q<P\TrQG(k[V]Q),\Bbbk[V]^G\Big/\sum_{Q<P}\Tr_Q^G\bigl(\Bbbk[V]^Q\bigr),

where PP is a Sylow pp-subgroup, is generated in degrees at most ∣G∣|G|. Over F2\mathbb F_2, take G=P=C2×C2G=P=C_2\times C_2 and

V=(\rad(F2P)⊕5)∗.V=\bigl(\rad(\mathbb F_2P)^{\oplus 5}\bigr)^*.

We prove that the corresponding transfer quotient has a nonzero algebra indecomposable in degree 55, although ∣G∣=4|G|=4. In fact, the squarefree multidegree (1,1,1,1,1)(1,1,1,1,1) contains a two-dimensional space of algebra indecomposables. We also exhibit an explicit 3030-monomial invariant representing a nonzero class in this space. \end{abstract}

\section{Statement of the counterexample}

Let P=C2×C2=⟨a,b⟩P=C_2\times C_2=\langle a,b\rangle and let k=\kk\Bbbk=\kk. For a kP\Bbbk P-module MM, define its transfer, or Brauer, quotient by

\BrP(M):=MP/∑Q<P\TrQP(MQ).\Br_P(M) := M^P\Big/ \sum_{Q<P}\Tr_Q^P(M^Q).

For a graded k\Bbbk-algebra AA with A0=kA_0=\Bbbk, write

Q(A):=A+/(A+)2Q(A):=A_+/(A_+)^2

for its space of algebra indecomposables.

\begin{theorem}\label{thm:counterexample} Let

Λ=\kkP,U=\rad(Λ),E=U1⊕⋯⊕U5\Lambda=\kk P, \qquad U=\rad(\Lambda), \qquad E=U_1\oplus\cdots\oplus U_5

with each Ui≅UU_i\cong U, and put

V=E∗,R=\kk[V]=\Sym(E).V=E^*, \qquad R=\kk[V]=\Sym(E).

If

J=∑Q<P\TrQP(RQ),R‾=RP/J,J=\sum_{Q<P}\Tr_Q^P(R^Q), \qquad \overline R=R^P/J,

then

dim⁡\kkQ(R‾)(1,1,1,1,1)=2.\dim_{\kk}Q(\overline R)_{(1,1,1,1,1)}=2.

In particular,

β(R‾)≥5>4=∣P∣,\beta(\overline R)\ge 5>4=|P|,

so the degree-bound conjecture for transfer quotients is false. \end{theorem}

The proof occupies Sections~\ref{sec:module} and~\ref{sec:multigraded}. Section~\ref{sec:explicit} gives an explicit indecomposable invariant.

\section{The three-dimensional module}\label{sec:module}

Write

s=a−1,t=b−1.s=a-1, \qquad t=b-1.

Since the characteristic is 22,

Λ≅\kk[s,t]/(s2,t2).\Lambda \cong \kk[s,t]/(s^2,t^2).

The radical

U=\rad(Λ)=(s,t)U=\rad(\Lambda)=(s,t)

has basis

x=st,y=t,z=s.x=st, \qquad y=t, \qquad z=s.

Left multiplication gives

a(x)=x,a(y)=y+x,a(z)=z,b(x)=x,b(y)=y,b(z)=z+x.\begin{array}{lll} a(x)=x, & a(y)=y+x, & a(z)=z,\\[2mm] b(x)=x, & b(y)=y, & b(z)=z+x. \end{array}

The key calculation is the following.

\begin{proposition}\label{prop:brauer-tensor} For every integer n≥1n\ge 1,

dim⁡\kk\BrP(U⊗n)=max⁡{n−3,0}.\dim_{\kk}\Br_P(U^{\otimes n})=\max\{n-3,0\}.

Thus

n12345dim⁡\kk\BrP(U⊗n)00012.\begin{array}{c|ccccc} n&1&2&3&4&5\\ \hline \dim_{\kk}\Br_P(U^{\otimes n})&0&0&0&1&2. \end{array}

\end{proposition}

\begin{proof} We divide the proof into four steps.

\medskip \noindent \textbf{Step 1: tensor powers and syzygies.} The augmentation sequence is

0⟶U⟶Λ→ε\kk⟶0.0\longrightarrow U \longrightarrow \Lambda \xrightarrow{\varepsilon}\kk \longrightarrow 0.

Tensoring over \kk\kk with a PP-module MM, with diagonal PP-action, gives

0⟶U⊗M⟶Λ⊗M⟶M⟶0.0\longrightarrow U\otimes M \longrightarrow \Lambda\otimes M \longrightarrow M \longrightarrow 0.

The middle term is free as a \kkP\kk P-module. Indeed, the map

g⊗m⟼g⊗g−1mg\otimes m\longmapsto g\otimes g^{-1}m

identifies the diagonal action on Λ⊗M\Lambda\otimes M with the action on the first tensor factor alone. By Schanuel's lemma,

U⊗M≃stΩ(M),U\otimes M\simeq_{\mathrm{st}}\Omega(M),

and hence, by iteration,

U⊗n≃stΩn(\kk).U^{\otimes n}\simeq_{\mathrm{st}}\Omega^n(\kk).

The Brauer quotient of a free module is zero. In fact,

ΛP=\kk(1+a+b+ab)=\kkst\Lambda^P=\kk(1+a+b+ab)=\kk st

and

st=\Tr1P(1).st=\Tr_1^P(1).

Therefore \BrP(Λ)=0\Br_P(\Lambda)=0, and additivity gives the same conclusion for all finite free modules. Stable isomorphism consequently implies

\BrP(U⊗n)≅\BrP(Ωn(\kk)).\Br_P(U^{\otimes n})\cong \Br_P(\Omega^n(\kk)).

\medskip \noindent \textbf{Step 2: an explicit free resolution.} For n≥0n\ge 0, let

Fn=Λn+1.F_n=\Lambda^{n+1}.

For n≥1n\ge 1, define

dn:Fn⟶Fn−1d_n:F_n\longrightarrow F_{n-1}

by

dn(c0,…,cn)=(sc0+tc1, sc1+tc2, …, scn−1+tcn),d_n(c_0,\ldots,c_n) = (sc_0+tc_1,\ sc_1+tc_2,\ \ldots,\ sc_{n-1}+tc_n),

and set d0=εd_0=\varepsilon. Since s2=t2=0s^2=t^2=0 and st=tsst=ts, one has dn−1dn=0d_{n-1}d_n=0.

We claim that this complex is exact. Let

m=(m0,…,mn−1)∈ker⁡dn−1.m=(m_0,\ldots,m_{n-1})\in\ker d_{n-1}.

Writing each mjm_j in the basis 1,s,t,st1,s,t,st and comparing coefficients shows that there are unique scalars

β0,…,βn,δ0,…,δn−1∈\kk\beta_0,\ldots,\beta_n, \delta_0,\ldots,\delta_{n-1}\in\kk

such that \begin{equation}\label{eq:kernel-form} m_j=\beta_js+\beta_{j+1}t+\delta_jst \qquad(0\le j\le n-1). \end{equation} Conversely, every vector of this form is in the image of dnd_n: take

cj=βj+δjt(0≤j<n),cn=βn.c_j=\beta_j+\delta_jt\quad(0\le j<n), \qquad c_n=\beta_n.

Then

scj+tcj+1=βjs+βj+1t+δjst.sc_j+tc_{j+1} =\beta_js+\beta_{j+1}t+\delta_jst.

Hence the complex is exact and

Ωn(\kk)=ker⁡dn−1⊆Λn.\Omega^n(\kk)=\ker d_{n-1}\subseteq \Lambda^n.

\medskip \noindent \textbf{Step 3: fixed points.} For 0≤j≤n−10\le j\le n-1, let wj∈Λnw_j\in\Lambda^n be the vector whose jjth coordinate is stst and whose other coordinates are zero. From \eqref{eq:kernel-form},

smj=βj+1st,tmj=βjst.sm_j=\beta_{j+1}st, \qquad tm_j=\beta_jst.

Thus mm is fixed by both a=1+sa=1+s and b=1+tb=1+t if and only if every βj\beta_j is zero. Therefore

Ωn(\kk)P=\Span\kk{w0,…,wn−1},\Omega^n(\kk)^P =\Span_{\kk}\{w_0,\ldots,w_{n-1}\},

so

dim⁡\kkΩn(\kk)P=n.\dim_{\kk}\Omega^n(\kk)^P=n.

\medskip \noindent \textbf{Step 4: transfers from the three maximal subgroups.} The maximal subgroups are

Qa=⟨a⟩,Qb=⟨b⟩,Qc=⟨ab⟩.Q_a=\langle a\rangle, \qquad Q_b=\langle b\rangle, \qquad Q_c=\langle ab\rangle.

Transfer from the trivial subgroup factors through every maximal subgroup, so these three subgroups suffice.

For QaQ_a, choose coset representatives 1,b1,b. Then

\TrQaP=1+b=t,Ωn(\kk)Qa=ker⁡s.\Tr_{Q_a}^P=1+b=t, \qquad \Omega^n(\kk)^{Q_a}=\ker s.

The condition sm=0sm=0 is equivalent to

β1=⋯=βn=0,\beta_1=\cdots=\beta_n=0,

and then tm=β0w0tm=\beta_0w_0. Hence

\TrQaP(Ωn(\kk)Qa)=\kkw0.\Tr_{Q_a}^P\bigl(\Omega^n(\kk)^{Q_a}\bigr)=\kk w_0.

Similarly,

\TrQbP=1+a=s,\TrQbP(Ωn(\kk)Qb)=\kkwn−1.\Tr_{Q_b}^P=1+a=s, \qquad \Tr_{Q_b}^P\bigl(\Omega^n(\kk)^{Q_b}\bigr)=\kk w_{n-1}.

Finally,

ab−1=(1+s)(1+t)−1=s+t+st=:u.ab-1=(1+s)(1+t)-1=s+t+st=:u.

For mm as in \eqref{eq:kernel-form},

umj=(βj+βj+1)st.um_j=(\beta_j+\beta_{j+1})st.

Thus um=0um=0 exactly when

β0=β1=⋯=βn.\beta_0=\beta_1=\cdots=\beta_n.

Choosing 1,a1,a as coset representatives gives

\TrQcP=1+a=s,\Tr_{Q_c}^P=1+a=s,

so

\TrQcP(Ωn(\kk)Qc)=\kk(w0+⋯+wn−1).\Tr_{Q_c}^P\bigl(\Omega^n(\kk)^{Q_c}\bigr) =\kk(w_0+\cdots+w_{n-1}).

The full proper-subgroup transfer subspace is therefore

\Span\kk{w0,wn−1,w0+⋯+wn−1}.\Span_{\kk} \bigl\{ w_0, w_{n-1}, w_0+\cdots+w_{n-1} \bigr\}.

Its dimension is 11 for n=1n=1, 22 for n=2n=2, and 33 for n≥3n\ge 3. Since the fixed-point space has dimension nn, we obtain

dim⁡\kk\BrP(Ωn(\kk))=max⁡{n−3,0}.\dim_{\kk}\Br_P(\Omega^n(\kk))=\max\{n-3,0\}.

Together with Step~1, this proves the proposition. \end{proof}

\section{The multigraded transfer quotient}\label{sec:multigraded}

Take five copies U1,…,U5U_1,\ldots,U_5 of UU and write their bases as

xi,yi,zi(1≤i≤5).x_i,y_i,z_i \qquad(1\le i\le 5).

Then

R=\Sym(U1⊕⋯⊕U5)=\kk[xi,yi,zi∣1≤i≤5],R=\Sym(U_1\oplus\cdots\oplus U_5) =\kk[x_i,y_i,z_i\mid 1\le i\le 5],

with action

a(xi)=xi,a(yi)=yi+xi,a(zi)=zi,b(xi)=xi,b(yi)=yi,b(zi)=zi+xi.\begin{aligned} a(x_i)&=x_i,& a(y_i)&=y_i+x_i,& a(z_i)&=z_i,\\ b(x_i)&=x_i,& b(y_i)&=y_i,& b(z_i)&=z_i+x_i. \end{aligned}

Give RR its N5\mathbb N^5-grading by declaring

deg⁡(xi)=deg⁡(yi)=deg⁡(zi)=ei,\deg(x_i)=\deg(y_i)=\deg(z_i)=e_i,

where eie_i is the iith standard basis vector. The PP-action, fixed-point spaces, and all transfer maps preserve this multigrading.

For a subset S⊆{1,…,5}S\subseteq\{1,\ldots,5\}, let \oneS∈{0,1}5\one_S\in\{0,1\}^5 be its indicator vector. The multihomogeneous component of degree \oneS\one_S is naturally a PP-module

R\oneS≅⨂i∈SUi≅U⊗∣S∣.R_{\one_S} \cong \bigotimes_{i\in S}U_i \cong U^{\otimes |S|}.

It follows degree by degree that \begin{equation}\label{eq:component-brauer} \overline R_{\one_S} \cong \Br_P(U^{\otimes |S|}). \end{equation} By Proposition~\ref{prop:brauer-tensor},

R‾\oneS=0for ∣S∣=1 or 2,\overline R_{\one_S}=0 \qquad\text{for }|S|=1\text{ or }2,

whereas

dim⁡\kkR‾(1,1,1,1,1)=2.\dim_{\kk}\overline R_{(1,1,1,1,1)}=2.

We now show that every element of this two-dimensional component is an algebra indecomposable. Consider

(R‾+)(1,1,1,1,1)2.(\overline R_+)^2_{(1,1,1,1,1)}.

A product of two positive multihomogeneous elements contributing to this component has multidegrees α,γ∈N5\alpha,\gamma\in\mathbb N^5 satisfying

α+γ=(1,1,1,1,1).\alpha+\gamma=(1,1,1,1,1).

Thus the supports of α\alpha and γ\gamma form a nontrivial partition

{1,…,5}=S⊔Sc.\{1,\ldots,5\}=S\sqcup S^c.

One of the two sets has cardinality at most 22. By \eqref{eq:component-brauer}, the corresponding factor lies in a zero component of R‾\overline R. Hence every such product is zero and

(R‾+)(1,1,1,1,1)2=0.(\overline R_+)^2_{(1,1,1,1,1)}=0.

Therefore

Q(R‾)(1,1,1,1,1)=R‾(1,1,1,1,1)Q(\overline R)_{(1,1,1,1,1)} =\overline R_{(1,1,1,1,1)}

has dimension 22. Its elements have total degree 55, so

β(R‾)≥5>4=∣P∣.\beta(\overline R)\ge 5>4=|P|.

This proves Theorem~\ref{thm:counterexample}.

\section{An explicit indecomposable invariant}\label{sec:explicit}

The dimension argument above already disproves the conjecture. We now give an explicit representative of a nonzero degree-55 indecomposable class.

For a word w=w1w2w3w4w5w=w_1w_2w_3w_4w_5 in the letters x,y,zx,y,z, define

mw=(w1)1(w2)2(w3)3(w4)4(w5)5,m_w=(w_1)_1(w_2)_2(w_3)_3(w_4)_4(w_5)_5,

where (x)i=xi(x)_i=x_i, (y)i=yi(y)_i=y_i, and (z)i=zi(z)_i=z_i. Let ρ\rho be cyclic left rotation of five-letter words, and set

C(w)=∑r=04mρr(w).C(w)=\sum_{r=0}^{4}m_{\rho^r(w)}.

Define \begin{equation}\label{eq:explicit-F} \begin{aligned} F={}&C(xxyyz)+C(xxzyy)+C(xyyyz)\ &+C(xyyzy)+C(xyzyy)+C(xzyyy). \end{aligned} \end{equation} This is a sum of 3030 distinct squarefree multihomogeneous monomials of total degree 55.

\begin{proposition}\label{prop:explicit} The polynomial FF lies in RPR^P, its class in R‾\overline R is nonzero, and that class is algebra indecomposable. \end{proposition}

\begin{proof} Put

Δa=a−1,Δb=b−1.\Delta_a=a-1, \qquad \Delta_b=b-1.

A direct expansion using a(yi)=yi+xia(y_i)=y_i+x_i gives \begin{align*} &\Delta_a\bigl(C(xxyyz)+C(xxzyy)+C(xyyyz)\bigr)\ &\qquad={} C(xxxxz)+C(xxxzy)+C(xxyyz)+C(xyxyz)+C(xyyxz), \end{align*} and the same expression is obtained from \begin{align*} &\Delta_a\bigl(C(xyyzy)+C(xyzyy)+C(xzyyy)\bigr). \end{align*} The two copies cancel in characteristic 22, so Δa(F)=0\Delta_a(F)=0.

Similarly, because bb replaces each ziz_i by zi+xiz_i+x_i,

ΔbC(xxyyz)=ΔbC(xxzyy)=C(xxxyy),ΔbC(xyyyz)=ΔbC(xzyyy)=C(xxyyy),ΔbC(xyyzy)=ΔbC(xyzyy)=C(xyxyy).\begin{aligned} \Delta_bC(xxyyz)&=\Delta_bC(xxzyy)=C(xxxyy),\\ \Delta_bC(xyyyz)&=\Delta_bC(xzyyy)=C(xxyyy),\\ \Delta_bC(xyyzy)&=\Delta_bC(xyzyy)=C(xyxyy). \end{aligned}

These terms cancel in pairs, and therefore Δb(F)=0\Delta_b(F)=0. Hence F∈RPF\in R^P.

It remains to prove that FF is not a sum of relative transfers. Work in

M=R(1,1,1,1,1)≅U⊗5.M=R_{(1,1,1,1,1)}\cong U^{\otimes 5}.

For a word ww, write [w][w] for the coefficient-extraction functional at mwm_w. Define

λ=[zyyyx]+[zzzyx],μa=[zyyxz]+[zzzxz],μb=[xyyyy]+[zzxyy],μc=[zxzyy]+[zyxyy].\begin{aligned} \lambda&=[zyyyx]+[zzzyx],\\ \mu_a&=[zyyxz]+[zzzxz],\\ \mu_b&=[xyyyy]+[zzxyy],\\ \mu_c&=[zxzyy]+[zyxyy]. \end{aligned}

Direct evaluation on the word basis gives the identities of linear functionals \begin{equation}\label{eq:functional-identities} \begin{aligned} \lambda\circ(1+b) &=\mu_a\circ(a-1) =[zyyyz]+[zzzyz],\ \lambda\circ(1+a) &=\mu_b\circ(b-1) =\mu_c\circ(ab-1) =[zyyyy]+[zzzyy]. \end{aligned} \end{equation}

Let Qa=⟨a⟩Q_a=\langle a\rangle. If h∈MQah\in M^{Q_a}, then, using coset representatives 1,b1,b,

λ(\TrQaP(h))=λ((1+b)h)=μa((a−1)h)=0.\begin{aligned} \lambda\bigl(\Tr_{Q_a}^P(h)\bigr) &=\lambda((1+b)h)\\ &=\mu_a((a-1)h)=0. \end{aligned}

If h∈M⟨b⟩h\in M^{\langle b\rangle}, then

λ(\Tr⟨b⟩P(h))=λ((1+a)h)=μb((b−1)h)=0.\lambda\bigl(\Tr_{\langle b\rangle}^P(h)\bigr) =\lambda((1+a)h) =\mu_b((b-1)h)=0.

Finally, if h∈M⟨ab⟩h\in M^{\langle ab\rangle}, choose coset representatives 1,a1,a and obtain

λ(\Tr⟨ab⟩P(h))=λ((1+a)h)=μc((ab−1)h)=0.\lambda\bigl(\Tr_{\langle ab\rangle}^P(h)\bigr) =\lambda((1+a)h) =\mu_c((ab-1)h)=0.

Transfer from the trivial subgroup factors through a maximal subgroup, so λ\lambda vanishes on the full proper-subgroup transfer subspace of MM.

On the other hand,

λ(F)=1.\lambda(F)=1.

Indeed, zyyyxzyyyx occurs once as a cyclic rotation of xzyyyxzyyy, whereas zzzyxzzzyx does not occur because every monomial of FF contains exactly one letter zz. Hence FF is not a relative transfer, so its class in R‾(1,1,1,1,1)\overline R_{(1,1,1,1,1)} is nonzero. Section~\ref{sec:multigraded} shows that the decomposable subspace in this multidegree is zero. Thus the class of FF is algebra indecomposable. \end{proof}

\section{Conclusion}

For

k=F2,G=P=C2×C2,V=(\rad(F2G)⊕5)∗,\Bbbk=\mathbb F_2, \qquad G=P=C_2\times C_2, \qquad V=\bigl(\rad(\mathbb F_2G)^{\oplus 5}\bigr)^*,

we have

0≠F‾∈Q(k[V]G/∑Q<G\TrQG(k[V]Q))5.0\ne \overline F \in Q\left( \Bbbk[V]^G \Big/ \sum_{Q<G}\Tr_Q^G(\Bbbk[V]^Q) \right)_5.

Therefore

β(k[V]G/∑Q<G\TrQG(k[V]Q))≥5>4=∣G∣.\boxed{ \beta\left( \Bbbk[V]^G \Big/ \sum_{Q<G}\Tr_Q^G(\Bbbk[V]^Q) \right) \ge 5>4=|G|. }

Thus the degree-bound conjecture is false.

\end{document}