The non-termination conjecture for the lower central series of two-strand braid groups on the projective plane

About 4 years old · traced to

Let m≥3m\geq 3, and let B2,m(P2){\mathbf{B}}_{2,m}({\mathbb{P}^2}) denote the relevant two-strand braid group on the projective plane with parameter mm. Its lower central series (LCS) is the sequence of iterated commutator subgroups.

Non-termination conjecture. The LCS of B2,m(P2){\mathbf{B}}_{2,m}({\mathbb{P}^2}) does not stop.

The preceding computations show that, for all m≤1024m\leq 1024 and for all m=2νm=2^\nu with ν≤23\nu\leq 23, the LCS does not stop before the 100th term. The conjecture asserts that this behavior continues indefinitely for every m≥3m\geq 3.

References

Primary source

Jacques Darné, Martin Palmer and Arthur Soulié, “When the lower central series stops: a comprehensive study for braid groups and their relatives”, arXiv:2201.03542 (2022).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open

The conjecture remains open: extensive computations support it, but no proof or counterexample has been found.

The conjecture asserts that the lower central series of B2,m(P2)\mathbf{B}_{2,m}(\mathbb{P}^{2}) never terminates for every m≥3m\geq 3. A 2022 study isolates this family as its sole unresolved case among the families examined.

Known results

  • Computations verify lower central series length at least 100100 for every m≤1024m\leq 1024.
  • Computations also verify length at least 100100 for m=2νm=2^{\nu} with ν≤23\nu\leq 23.
  • These are finite computations and do not establish non-termination for all mm or indefinitely many terms.

2022 unresolved-case classification

The comprehensive study labels the assertion Conjecture 6.94 and explicitly leaves B2,m(P2)\mathbf{B}_{2,m}(\mathbb{P}^{2}), m≥3m\geq 3, unresolved. The scan found no subsequent proof, counterexample, claimed solution, verification, gap report, or retraction concerning this exact conjecture.

Current status (as of August 2026): The finite computational checks are established, but non-termination for every m≥3m\geq 3 remains unproved, with no known counterexample.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.