The dual spectral-set conjecture for spectra and tiling sets
Let . A spectrum is a set for which there exists a set such that is a spectral pair, and a tiling set is a set for which there exists a set such that is a tiling pair. The dual spectral-set conjecture. is a spectrum if and only if is a tiling set, i.e., there exists a set so that is a spectral pair if and only if there exists a set so that is a tiling pair. This is formulated as the dual counterpart of Fuglede's spectral-set conjecture; its general validity remains open.
References
- Palle E. T. Jorgensen and Steen Pedersen, “Spectral pairs in Cartesian coordinates”, arXiv:math/9912131 (2001).
Progress summary
The equivalence is known in a narrow one-dimensional setting, but no general proof or counterexample has been found.
The conjecture asks whether the same set can serve as the frequency set for a spectral pair and as the translation set for a tiling pair. It is presented as the dual counterpart of Fuglede’s conjecture; a 2010 survey records it explicitly as open.
Known results
- In one dimension, for a union of two translated lattices, spectrality is equivalent to being a tiling set; the lattices need not be disjoint.
- For disjoint lattices, a weaker version holds for possibly unbounded sets of finite positive measure.
- The result is restricted to dimension one and leaves the analogous question for open.
Current status (as of August 2026): The conjecture is proved only for the recorded one-dimensional two-lattice class; its general validity, including higher dimensions, remains open, with no publicly reported proof, counterexample, or verification.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.