Common-root conjecture for truncated binomials
For integers and , let and denote the truncated binomial polynomials used in the paper. Common-root conjecture. The polynomials and do not have common roots. This is the additional condition needed for non-degeneracy in the case ; the source does not establish it for all .
References
- I. Scherbak, “Intersections of Schubert varieties and highest weight vectors in tensor products of sl_N+1-representations”, arXiv:math/0409329 (2005).
Progress summary
A proof has been reported, but no retrieved source independently checks it, so the conjecture is not verified.
The conjecture says that the truncated binomials and have no common root whenever . A 2004 paper reports that Inna Scherbak later resolved the related question using representation theory, but does not give the proof.
Known results
- The 2004 paper proves that, for prime , each is irreducible for .
- It also proves that the number of distinct roots is asymptotic to as .
- Scherbak's reported representation-theoretic resolution is not supplied or independently assessed in the retrieved record.
March 2026 claimed solution
A March 5, 2026 report claims that Carl Pomerance gave a proof, with ChatGPT producing an argument; this remains unverified. A submission dated October 24, 2026 cites Peikai Qi's paper and claims a proof covering the interior and boundary cases, but that paper was not independently retrieved.
Community submission (unverified)
A submitted argument claims that Qi's Theorem 3.5 gives coprimality after the stated change of variables, with Remark 3.6 handling ; its correctness is unverified.
Current status (as of October 2026): The conjecture has reported proofs, including a recent submitted claim, but no retrieved source verifies them, so the general statement remains open.
Solutions 1
Scherbak's common-root conjecture is proved in Peikai Qi, Partial Results on Common Roots of Positive Derivatives of Geometric Sums (2026). Theorem 3.5 establishes coprimality for a more general family of polynomials. The conjecture follows by a change of variables, with the remaining boundary case handled in Remark 3.6.See full solution
The conjecture is resolved in the following paper:
Peikai Qi, Partial Results on Common Roots of Positive Derivatives of Geometric Sums (2026).
Define
Theorem 3.5 establishes that
Using the identity
the result implies that and have no common roots whenever .
The remaining boundary case is established in Remark 3.6.
Consequently, Scherbak's common-root conjecture holds for all .