The conjecture that planar-move graphs differ from knot-move graphs

Let C1{\cal C}_1 be the set of graphs isotopic to planar graphs, C2{\cal C}_2 the set of graphs isotopic to graphs obtained from planar graphs by the specified moves, C3{\cal C}_3 the set of graphs isotopic to graphs obtained from knots, including the unknot, by those moves, and C4{\cal C}_4 the set of graphs whose polynomial PP equals 11. The known inclusions are C1C2C3C4{\cal C}_1\subseteq{\cal C}_2\subseteq{\cal C}_3\subseteq{\cal C}_4.

The conjecture that C2{\cal C}_2 and C3{\cal C}_3 differ.

C2C3.{\cal C}_2\neq{\cal C}_3.

The question concerns whether the classes generated from planar graphs and from knots by the allowed graph moves coincide; the source gives the preceding inclusions and an example proving C1C2{\cal C}_1\neq{\cal C}_2, but no resolution of this separation is supplied.

Sources & referencesView supporting material

Primary source

Rui Pedro Carpentier, “Topological notions for Kauffman and Vogel's polynomial”, arXiv:math/0204207 (2002).

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.